6 ms·
The problem with downvoting (at least simple versions) is that it allows separate communities to interfere which each others' communications. So, say you have h
by skybrian 11y ago
The problem with downvoting (at least simple versions) is that it allows separate communities to interfere which each others' communications. So, say you have hunters and animal-rights activists. They should be able to talk among themselves on Google+, Twitter, or Facebook without interference from the other side. You don't want one side to start downvoting the other side's posts into oblivion so they can't even talk among themselves.
Downvoting works okay in places like Hacker News that are basically a single community with good moderation and some common values. It doesn't work in large-scale systems where many distinct communities have little in common beyond using the same social network. The average for a controversial post isn't going to tell you much.
Perhaps some form of negative feedback would be helpful; an intelligent system could use it to avoid sharing posts into communities where they're not wanted. But the system could probably figure this out from people not upvoting or resharing things.
- derekp7 11y agoI've often thought the same thing, that the score you see should be based on your own voting history. Either based on you voting specifically, or agreeing / disagreeing with existing votes. Extend it even further by having posts from people that you normally agree with get highlighted even if they haven't had upvotes for the specific post. Just out of curiosity, how much of that data is available via HN's public API (or other large enough forum)? I'd like to see someone run some analysis on it to see if up/down votes do tend to cluster like this.
- fapjacks 11y agoI know specifically of one community that tracks these metrics internally (Stack Overflow) and from which there is also a specific term for someone that mostly only downvotes things ("Vampire").
- Kalium 11y agoA lot of people believe it's their right to disrupt the communities of others. They call it "activism" or "advocacy" or "defending family values" or whatever the justification du jour is. It's all basically trying to stake a claim to the whole service as the territory of your tribe. I like the idea of reinforcing some separation, but I also fear it may be too late. A lot of people seem to derive joy from attacking the community of others, to the point where that's the focal point of some whole communities. Trying to stop this internecine fighting really is an attack on such communities...
- CWuestefeld 11y agoIMHO, the problem is not disruption by outsiders. The worst cesspools I see are entirely in-group. It seems to me that the in-group echo chamber becomes not a discussion, but a means for all to signal their right-thinking loyal membership of the group. Just over the last couple of days I've seen some awful stuff along these lines on Facebook, regarding the new opening on the Supreme Court. Someone will share a meme that was posted by one of their in-group pages. This turns into a bunch of "me too" replies, but each of them needs to share a comment that includes a non-clever pun based on misspelling an opponent's name, and many of which declare how evil the other side is and deserves whatever they get. (notice I'm not taking sides: I think this applies equally across the board) The problem here is that from a few cheers that get the ball rolling, any semblance of discussion evaporates. It's like when the neighbor's dog barks in the middle of the night, so your own dog replies, and then another gets into the act, and pretty soon the cacophony has everyone awake - but nobody's any better off from knowing that there are a bunch of dogs in the neighborhood. I don't know what the solution is, but I don't think that the problem is outsiders being disruptive - it's insiders clambering to signal their tribal membership. EDIT: missed the "not" in first sentence. BIG difference!
- Kalium 11y agoI'd go so far as to say that attacking someone else's tribe and poison their territory is one of the stronger ways to signal tribal membership.
- CWuestefeld 11y agoSure - but the signal can only be heard from within your in-group's discussion. So they'll generally flock together taking potshots at the outgroup from afar. There are of course cases of drive-bys, but that's harder to organize and rarer.
- skybrian 11y agoWell, yes, there's no system that's truly value-neutral. (What would that even mean?) But generally speaking, I expect that the large social networks will try not to encourage open conflict between groups that would otherwise keep to themselves, to avoid driving members away. So this is a bias towards peacefulness rather than conflict. One example of this is how resharing a post on Google+ starts a new comment thread underneath it. This allows posts to cross communities while somewhat discouraging them from mixing it up in the comments. (You can click on the original if you want to.) The web does this too: a web page can be discussed in any number of forums, independently of each other, without conflict, by sharing the URL. Comments directly on the web page don't work that way, which is why they're so often worse. If people are deliberately trying to fight, things get even more difficult. Banning people from your feed can sometimes work, but is vulnerable to sock-puppetry and doesn't scale to large groups.
- scrollaway 11y agoIn computer science, when we have too much data to process at once, we shard it. We separate it into manageable chunks and we stop looking at every single data point and just at summaries. I was using this very analogy to explain the advent of CCG "formats" (MTG, Hearthstone) a few days ago and it seems like the same analogy could be used here. There is a point where a discussion/dicussion room contains too much data to be manageable and the only way to fix that is to break it up into chunks. We see it on Reddit, too, with subreddits becoming "too big" and naturally breaking up into smaller subreddits. I suspect there's a universal truth hidden in there somewhere.
- Loughla 11y agoIt's the upper limit on our ability to process information. Whether it's data, or whether it's a social circle. I believe we will (until AI is a thing) be constrained and will fail, simply because of our poor ability to store and process information as humans.
- hueving 11y agoBut your defending the problem we have now. People are encouraged to get into feedback loops and not ever see anything that disagrees with them. If you're a hunter or animal rights activist, it would be much better for you to be reminded that there are people out there that disagree with you.
- zazen 11y agoThis is a very interesting question: when does a community become an echo chamber? To use the hunting example: I imagine sometimes the hunters talk about stuff to do with hunting itself; the merits of different rifles, or where to find game, or whatever. And this is a reasonable community discussion for them to have, and it wouldn't help to have activists shouting "hunting is evil" over conversations such as that. But sometimes the hunters will talk about the politics of hunting: one will say, "those activists are wrong to complain about animals suffering, because <reasons here>", and then another will say "yes, it's so obvious they're wrong, because <reasons> are so obviously right", and the echo chamber is ringing - this is the situation where people ideally would be brought into contact with the opposing view. Can an online community promote the first type of conversation while challenging the other? How would we set about that?
- adrianN 11y agoThat's the job of good moderation I think.
- zazen 11y agoPerhaps. But I think it would take a particularly far-sighted and philosophical moderator to down-vote/remove a perfectly civil post whose message he agreed with, _just_ because it was contributing to an echo-chamber effect.
- derefr 11y agoI would think this could be accomplished with just a policy to never, ever discuss the politics of the community's niche, and to remove posts that do.
- overdrivetg 11y agoIf you're thinking along these lines, you'll enjoy reading this post[1] by Venkatesh Rao. Stephen Fry leaving is the exact scenario of "evaporative cooling" expressed there, and you are exactly describing the process of "warrenization" that is required for large-scale online communities to survive and thrive. Obviously Twitter has failed in including these insights into their social architecture, to their detriment[2]. [1] http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2010/12/07/socratic-fishing-in-lake-quora/ http://www.ribbonfarm.com/2010/12/07/socratic-fishing-in-lak... [2] http://techcrunch.com/2016/02/10/trying-to-fly-with-broken-wings/ http://techcrunch.com/2016/02/10/trying-to-fly-with-broken-w...
- c_c_c 11y agoThis is off topic (sorry), but I'm an animal rights activist and I have no problem with hunting or hunters. As long as the animal is consumed as food, no problem. Trophy hunters are a different story.
- michaelmrose 11y agoWhat about letting people decide whose votes they want to count for them. You can be as meta as you want to be with this. I don't want to count the votes of anyone my friend considers an idiot. I don't want to count the vote of anyone whose tagged as a #foo by anyone tagged as a #bar by such and such a group. Alternatively you want their vote to count double. Instead of a single score you have as many scores as you have users and its impossible to interfere much in others affairs. I think that this could be a very important improvement.
- _0ffh 11y agoIt's been obvious for a very long time that up-/downvoting is just a horribly broken mechanism. Much more so, if it's upvoting only. Twitter tries to ameliorate that with the ability to block people, but that's just a crutch. The solution is laughably simple in theory, but it seems to keep getting ignored: Don't use a simple sum of votes. Instead use some method - any method really - to weight the votes of users depending how much their past voting behaviour correlates with your own. I've been writing about this over six years ago, for example here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2095500 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2095500