5 ms·
I don't think Twitter is making things worse than they used to be. Society has the problem. Twitter just makes it public. Remember, the US used to have anti-c
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
I don't think Twitter is making things worse than they used to be.
Society has the problem. Twitter just makes it public.
Remember, the US used to have anti-communist witch hunts in which people were forced to give up their careers, it had actual physical lynchings, and it still has a culture where the police can do more or less whatever they want with limited accountability.
People being disrespectful or even stalkerish on a social network isn't good news, but it's a long way short of the very bad things that happen regularly offline.
If anything Twitter's problem is more that it works well for promoting celebrity vapidity, but less well for providing a mass audience for the stories of ordinary people.
You could argue there's not much interest in the latter, but then we're back to society having the problem, and Twitter being a medium for a certain expression of it.
I think Quora does a much better job of dealing with real stories and relatively civil debate - but I'd guess it's much less popular than Twitter.
- braythwayt 11y ago> Society has the problem. Twitter just makes it public. Every tool, every medium, has some effect on its content. It makes something things easy, others difficult. It amplifies some channels, squelches others. It speeds some things up, slows others down. Society has all sorts of wonderful things and terrible things. But we humans choose which tools to build and which media to promote. We can observe this and criticize choices accordingly.
- askafriend 11y agoSo you would prefer to build tools to mask society's problems instead of uncovering them so that we can stare them in the face and have some type of discussion about them? (Just playing devil's advocate here)
- braythwayt 11y agoThat's not playing devil's advocate, it's constructing a false dichotomy. As a counter-example, are you saying that the best way to have a discussion about Young Earthers is to give them equal space in every geology textbook? I don't think you're saying that, and I don't think I'm saying that we as a society should mask our problems.
- askafriend 11y agoTwitter isn't a textbook though. It's goals as a communications platform are completely different. It's like saying, would you rather design SMS around masking Young Earther's ideas? In the 20s, you would have had these services designed around not conversating about alcohol. Is that right? Is it wrong? I don't know if it's for the communications platform to decide. However the communications platform can provide the user tools to control what/who they hear from so that they can make those decisions themselves.
- braythwayt 11y ago> Twitter isn't a textbook though. It's goals as a communications platform are completely different Twitter is a company. Its goals and the way it tries to achieve the are as subject to discussion and criticism as any other company. As for the rest of your comment, you keep talking about “masking” when I never used that word. I conclude that you have a preconceived idea of what I am saying, and are arguing with that. Since it isn’t what I’m saying, I have no obligation to defend it, or even explain why when you put words in my mouth, the difference between your words and my words are. When you begin an argument with “So what you’re saying, is...” I need go no further than to say “No." > However the communications platform can provide the user tools to... And now you are talking about how Twitter could change its offering to improve the lives of its users. Which is what I was talking about. Seems like a good place to break off.
- askafriend 11y agoIt seems we are actually in agreement then! I apologize for misreading. I think it's the "which media to promote" bit which may have thrown me off. Cheers!
- lmm 11y agoI think Twitter by its very nature promotes that kind of thing. The 140-character limit inherently pushes towards zingers and outrage. Nuance is stripped away by the medium.
- Touche 11y agoThis should be upvoted more. Also I'd say the stream is part of the problem. Your tweet disappears from the stream quickly. The more noticeable it is, the more likely it is to have a life > 5 min.
- potatolicious 11y agoExactly - it's too easy to say that Twitter is simply a reflection of society itself, technology is not a completely neutral pass-through filter. The 140-character limit strips all nuance out of conversation, so it's no surprise that when it comes to controversial topics everyone is an asshole. It turns out we need more than 140 chars when talking about complicated, important topics. More than that, Twitter's choice of how users relate to each other also contributes to the nastiness - it's a medium specifically designed so that a single message can traverse a huge portion of the user graph, and this causes a lot of problems. On Facebook, if you post something stupid, insensitive, or generally moronic, at worst you'd have your friends (or friends-of-friends) telling you off, it almost never goes beyond that simply by nature of how friending works. FB's privacy settings (by default at least) literally prevents anything from being shared past N distance from you. Ditto on old-school web forums - if you post something stupid, insensitive, or generally moronic, you'll at worst be dogpiled by the forum's own users, but that's it. The link may be spread around, but few people will sign up to some new phpBB webforum just to yell at your stupidity. On Twitter though your tweet goes viral and traverses many, many different communities, each of which get to layer their own outrage on. More than that, they are all free to respond to you, without filters. The pile-on effect is the scariest we've seen from any social network in existence. Reddit also suffers from a similar problem - communities cross into each other almost too easily, so brigades are common. At the very least though most subreddits are moderated, whereas Twitter is really a free for all. We've seen how well Twitter's abuse team handles overt death threats and other far-beyond-the-pale abuse (read: lol). This might not be particularly insightful coming from someone who never really got into Twitter, but their whole model of user interaction is fundamentally defective.
- volaski 11y ago> Society has the problem. Twitter just makes it public. Yes. Thereby making things worse than they used to be.
- monksy 11y ago> Remember, the US used to have anti-communist witch hunts in which people were forced to give up their careers, it had actual physical lynchings, and it still has a culture where the police can do more or less whatever they want with limited accountability. Which twitter has and encourages. It's called "bluelisting."
- jacques_chester 11y agoYes, it's a human dynamic. In other spheres of interaction we've evolved mechanisms to cope. I wrote about this a few years ago[0]. But for the day to day situation, Stephen Fry has made the sensible choice. There's no point drinking from a well people keep re-poisoning. [0] http://chester.id.au/2013/03/22/why-the-law-is-slow-impersonal-and-obsessed/ http://chester.id.au/2013/03/22/why-the-law-is-slow-imperson...
- yummyfajitas 11y agoRemember, the US used to have anti-communist witch hunts in which people were forced to give up their careers,... Actually we still have those, and twitter often plays an important role. C.f. Pax Dickinson, Justine Sacco or Brandon Eich. Luckily we've moved beyond lynchings and other such political terrorism in the US. It still seems to happen in Europe, however: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jan/26/french-taxi-drivers-block-paris-roads-in-uber-protest http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/jan/26/french-taxi-dri... http://www.theguardian.com/business/live/2015/nov/12/greek-general-strike-against-austerity-measures-business-live http://www.theguardian.com/business/live/2015/nov/12/greek-g...
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoYour prison system has been described as a slow-motion Holocaust and the new Jim Crow. Does that not count as political terrorism? Or is this the same linguistic problem where 3000 dead in an intentionally collapsed building in NYC is terrorism, but two million killed by intentionally collapsing a middle-eastern state doesn't really have a word that we can use, so it seems harder to grasp somehow.