4 ms·
The problem isn't that this is a Twitter problem. It's that this is a cultural problem. People kinda suck. People kinda suck a lot. I was having a conversation
by moron4hire 11y ago
The problem isn't that this is a Twitter problem. It's that this is a cultural problem. People kinda suck. People kinda suck a lot.
I was having a conversation with a friend at lunch, when I started putting ketchup on my hotdog. He looked at me and incredulously questioned, "really? What are you, like, 8 years old?" I had never even heard of the idea that "only children put ketchup on a hotdog." Yet here was someone I had originally thought of as a rational human being elevating it to a serious issue.
A lot of this stuff gets defended as "just a joke", but I don't see anyone laughing. If you're so bad at making jokes, maybe you should just give up the practice and stick to being generally pleasant to be around.
I guess I'm lucky that I'm not famous enough to get any randos following me on Twitter. The people who follow me are interested in my work, they aren't hero-worshipping me. I get to have excellent conversations with people on Twitter. But that is only because--even though it's not 100% in my control--my lack of celebrity allows me to guide and design my Twitter sphere. For a celebrity, they just get inundated with folks they don't want to hear from.
Just read the replies to Notch's tweets sometime. I'm surprised he hasn't become a complete recluse. Almost every single one has some 13 year old complaining about "Minecraft sucks now that you're gone", even though he's been gone longer than they've been playing it.
- Kiro 11y agoWhere are you from? I'm very surprised anyone would even consider eating hotdog without ketchup so it must be a cultural thing.
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoIt's a capital crime in Chicago, if you do it in public. That's where the joking about it comes from; ketchup on hot dogs is one of those things that people take jestingly serious with tongue firmly planted in cheek at all times. Nobody actually cares, nobody's actually going to kill you in Chicago despite my joke, but people interpret the joshing as caring and demeaning because nobody can actually take a joke any more, as evidenced by GP (and which is far more often the problem). And yet here we are, lamenting the downfall of society. I can't even fathom a world where someone giving a friend crap over lunch for their choice of condiment is enough to start a Serious Conversation about Culture. That's funny in itself, honestly, but I don't want to live in that world. That's why I eschew social media altogether. I remember when I was a boy, laughing was something to be celebrated, because sharing something funny with your friends was one of the high points of life. Actually cutting loose and laughing with your friends about the stupidest things is easily one of the best feelings you can experience, but now every time I genuinely laugh at something that I find funny, I often have to look around and be worried about who saw me do it. It's genuinely depressing, the older I get. I don't even have humor any more. Now I just have liquor.
- moron4hire 11y agoSee, you're part of the problem. You think you understand my friend's tone better now that I'm relating it to you better than I did at the time that I experienced it. You don't believe my version of the story, even though the only evidence you have is my telling of it. You've treated me as if I'm lying to you, yet you don't just come out and say it. This is the very definition of passive aggressive behavior. Just because something is post hoc declared as a joke doesn't mean it was a joke. And just because something is styled as a joke, doesn't mean it is funny. I don't have a problem with taking jokes. Most people just suck at humor. It's not an easy thing to tell a joke. And besides, most people are just using "it was a joke" as an excuse to cover up for some serious comment they made that went over like a lead balloon.
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoActually, I believe your version completely and don't think you're lying at all from your perspective. What makes you think I feel otherwise? This is an odd, and overly defensive, reaction to something that you've clearly misinterpreted. (That sounds familiar.)
- moron4hire 11y agoHow could I have so clearly misinterpreted "GP can't take a joke" to be a refutation of my assertion the guy wasn't joking? Must be you were also telling a joke and I just don't get jokes.
- jsmthrowaway 11y agoSee, you think it's personal and that I've made some kind of determination on your character based on my conclusion. You've totally come off the rails and started attacking me personally at the mere suspicion (not even to you!) that you might have misinterpreted things. I've merely read and worked with the information that was made available; you call this person a friend, for example. You were having lunch with this person. This person felt comfortable enough with you to remark upon your condiment choice. I've observed many, many people remark upon the same choice in a jesting fashion. Now, which is more likely from my perspective: that a misinterpretation by you is at work (and which is spilling over here, since you clearly don't have closure on this egregious scenario), or that your friend is the one person out of millions who actually cares about ketchup on a hot dog and was ready to fight with you about it? Someone you identify as a friend chose ketchup on a hot dog as his Maginot Line in your relationship and demeaned you over it. Okay, maybe that did happen (in which case you should think long and hard about who you identify as friends), but my point was it's extraordinarily unlikely, and you cannot fault me for concluding that in my own time and with the facts given. You can't relay a story and then expect everyone to blindly accept your interpretation without reading objectively. That's unfair. I think you very likely misinterpreted things, yes, and I base that on the entire story including believing your perspective entirely. I don't think you're lying at all. That's the entire point, that I think you're telling the truth from your perspective, and your perspective might be a little bit off. It's nothing negative. I don't think less of you. I see misunderstanding like this all the time. Yet you felt passionately enough about it to go after me personally and call me part of the problem, simply because I didn't subscribe immediately to a half story. I feel I'm exercising the better option: I'm reading objectively and drawing my own conclusions rather than immediately buying into a single-sided narrative. That's what we should do when confronted with unfamiliar situations relayed by people we don't know, because it's the fundamental brick in the foundation of avoiding mobs, rash conclusions, beheading people over blogs, and so on. And see? Now we're arguing about this. About ketchup on a god damned hot dog. Remember how I didn't want to live in this world? (Edit: Also, please, please, please tell me you didn't compare your choice of condiment to the plight of minorities in an upthread comment. I will conclude something about your character after reading something like that, if you mean it.)
- moron4hire 11y agoI usually like them with chilli, but whatever. The point wasn't the hotdog. The point was that "I can't believe you like a thing I don't like" is pervasive in our culture. Things could be political candidates or sports teams or sex positions or music genres or entire races of people. We have figured out that it's not good to do that to gay people or black people, but somehow we haven't figured out it's not good to do it in general.
- csixty4 11y agoIn Chicago, you're lucky they don't ban you from setting foot in the Loop for putting ketchup on a hot dog. http://www.chicagotribune.com/dining/ct-chicago-ketchup-hot-dog-20150714-story.html http://www.chicagotribune.com/dining/ct-chicago-ketchup-hot-...
- Zikes 11y agoPeople do suck, but platforms can do a lot to mitigate that. All they have to do is make it a lot more difficult for harassers to create extra accounts. That's all. Then their existing reporting/flagging systems will have some actual bite to them, since shutting down an account will actually be consequential.
- mentos 11y agoThe best and worst traits of humanity have been amplified by computers and the internet. How can the better traits prevail? Feels like a sequel to Mike Judge's Idiocracy
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- brandon272 11y agoI don't think that your friend considered his remark to be a joke worthy of a laugh, but it sounds like "good natured ribbing" over something entirely benign. It's a social technique employed by many people on a day to day basis as a bonding method where no offense is usually intended and no offense is usually taken. Where your friend failed, in my opinion, is that he should recognize that not everyone is receptive to or appreciates this kind of teasing. It's up to him to identify the "line" that should not be crossed with some people and then not cross it.
- moron4hire 11y agoI don't think I need a rando on the internet to explain what ribbing means to me.
- brandon272 11y agoI apologize! It seemed like you did. Have a nice day.
- avar 11y agoInstead of making condescending comments towards people that are just trying to engage you in conversation you could take a leaf out of your own book and "just give up the practice and stick to being generally pleasant to be around" :)
- simoneau 11y agoZe Frank has a great piece on how we make fun of other people for what they like, and why we should stop ourselves from doing it. "Don't Yuck My Yum": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=knro0i2JH44 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=knro0i2JH44