3 ms·
I've always found it odd that the video game industry hasn't put as much focus on improving speech synthesis as they do on 3D graphics. They would be the ones t
by Razengan 11y ago
I've always found it odd that the video game industry hasn't put as much focus on improving speech synthesis as they do on 3D graphics. They would be the ones to benefit the most from more natural text-to-speech.
Seems to me that back when games used to be in text, you got to have more elaborate storylines because the developers and writers themselves could just add and improve the dialogue at any time. See Planescape: Torment [1], regarded to have one of the most complex stories in a game, with enough dialogue to rival a novel, but most of it is in text. Same for Star Control 2 [2] which was the inspiration behind Mass Effect.
Now, when everyone wants to be Hollywood and voice-acting is the norm, and expected by players for a game to be considered high-quality, stories are locked in to whatever was recorded in the studio at the time. This is also probably the reason for the discrepancy between the dialogue choices you see onscreen, versus what your character actually says (such as in Mass Effect and Fallout 4 and many others, where you just to get choose between something like "Joke" or "Threaten" and it sometimes spawns a very unexpected chain of conversation.)
Better speech synthesis would not only empower solo developers to write engrossing stories and complex dialogues from the comfort of their bedrooms, like they used to, it'd also open up better player customization in RPGs and online games, when whatever you type would be spoken to other players in your preferred voice.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planescape:_Torment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Planescape:_Torment
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Control_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star_Control_II
- sliverstorm 11y agoIt would be convenient, certainly, the same way a robot kitchen would be convenient. But it turns out human chefs aren't all that expensive compared to an equally competent robot chef, at least for the foreseeable future. The video game industry already has lifelike speech available to it, for a cost. Lifelike 3D graphics on the other hand don't exist at any cost.
- Razengan 11y agoBut with human voice actors, you can't modify the dialogue in your game, or change/improve the part of the story that's tied to that dialogue, without scheduling new recording sessions. That can get expensive and actors aren't always going to be available (which is another problem when you're trying to make sure you get the same voices for DLC & sequels etc.)
- sliverstorm 11y agoYes, I understand why it would be nice to have arbitrary lifelike synthesizable voice. But hiring a voice actor currently gets you 90% of the way "there" (wherever "there" is) at a tiny, tiny, minuscule fraction of the cost of personally developing the entire future of speech synthesis.