2 ms·
The other big problem is that curating search results is inherently about prioritising a position rather than establishing a sourced and reasonably neutral vers
by notahacker 11y ago
The other big problem is that curating search results is inherently about prioritising a position rather than establishing a sourced and reasonably neutral version of the truth.
I'm imagining the edit wars and debates that take place on contentious wordings or facts in some parts of Wikipedia, but on a much wider scale involving hundreds of SEO consultants each aware that changing a particular criterion will have a quantifiable impact on their clients' bottom line. It doesn't sound like it would be fun to police.
- abalone 11y agoWikipedia already curates links to some extent on every page under "External Links". So there is a seed there. And even the page text is not immune from the problem you describe. Grading and prioritizing sources is a fundamental part of producing a "reasonably neutral version of the truth." It's what determines what gets cited and how prominently it influences the article. So while I wouldn't equate text and links in terms of the difficulty of managing POV-neutrality, I would say they sit on a spectrum.