3 ms·
Every navigation device I've used will show the estimated drive time, distance, and a map. I always do a quick sanity check on these before I start following th
by mikeash 11y ago
Every navigation device I've used will show the estimated drive time, distance, and a map. I always do a quick sanity check on these before I start following the directions. Do other people not do this?
- jpatokal 11y agoOn many GPS models, including my own crusty Garmin, this requires an additional tap and a longish wait while it renders the map as an illegible squiggle. So I rarely do this unless I want to confirm that I'm going via a specific route, and even then it's only useful if I know the route options beforehand and can tell them apart. As an aside, the Garmin routing is terrible: it (for example) frequently "optimizes" for distance by doing endless zigzags on small roads instead of a single turn on big roads, even when the settings tell it to take the "best" or the "fastest" route. Of course this is to some degree unavoidable when all the brains it has is a tiny on-board CPU; but I've already long since resolved that my next car will have Android Auto, so the cloud can do the work.
- ghaff 11y ago>As an aside, the Garmin routing is terrible: it (for example) frequently "optimizes" for distance by doing endless zigzags on small roads instead of a single turn on big roads Google sometimes does this as well. I joke that it seems as if Google Maps sometimes just wants to take a drive in the country. Not that I always mind but, especially if the weather isn't great, I'd probably prefer the simpler route even if it theoretically takes a minute more.
- Pxtl 11y agoSome say arrival time, not drive time. Arrival time misleading if it's sending you on. A 26-hour journey, and you have to choose to view the full route, often through a tedious UI. IMHO, this is a place where blaming the user is inappropriate. GPS trips exceeding 3 hours are rare enough that it would be perfectly reasonable for it to make you click through a few extra bits of information in those cases.
- mikeash 11y agoI can buy the case for improving the systems, but not blaming the users? These things don't claim to be more than they are: they are driving aids, not brain substitutes. If it's hard to figure out if they're giving you appropriate advice, then you do it anyway, or don't use them. If manufacturers were making grandiose claims then yeah, blame them. But if anything, the claims are overly conservative because they're afraid of liability.