3 ms·
Rural roads in the United States are something to be especially wary of when using OpenStreetMap derived maps. They are often un-updated TIGER data from 2008, p
by maxerickson 11y ago
Rural roads in the United States are something to be especially wary of when using OpenStreetMap derived maps. They are often un-updated TIGER data from 2008, prior to Census doing a big push on accuracy. There are issues with roads being poorly located (or not existing), but there are also issues with little or no differentiation between roads, so a nice new asphalt highway might be classed the same as a barely passable dirt road.
One reasonable strategy would be to stick to things that are labeled as state or US highways.
(with enough scale, it should be possible to use traffic data to figure out which roads should be prioritized, but programs like OSMAnd are not yet doing that)
- ghaff 11y ago>with enough scale, it should be possible to use traffic data to figure out which roads should be prioritized It wouldn't be perfect but, yeah, I'd expect to see some correlation between traffic and road condition--at least for a given area. There's just a lot of nuance in road condition though. People who take their Jeeps off the beaten track every weekend in national forests and parks have a pretty different set of standards from an urbanite who is renting a car with a doughnut spare and no other special gear.
- maxerickson 11y agoThe goal with OSM is certainly to sensibly classify roads and even to collect information like the surface type and width. I guess with that part of the comment I was partly wondering if other data providers have done similar things, taking some vaguely useful source data and trying to enhance it using automated methods, leading to the poor navigation talked about in various threads here.