3 ms·
I shortened the headline because, well, it didn't fit...and also, I think "silences minorities" is a little strong. If the 538 map [1] in question aimed to argu
by danso 11y ago
I shortened the headline because, well, it didn't fit...and also, I think "silences minorities" is a little strong. If the 538 map [1] in question aimed to argue something along the lines of, "Why do minorities have so much voting power when they represent so little of the country?"...then sure. But sometimes a standard choropleth is used when geopolitical boundaries and distinctions are important. I'm not sure that they're particularly important for "The Facebook Primary"...on the other hand, in the context of presidential elections, geopolitical boundaries are generally more relevant to the reader...because of the way presidents are decided via electoral college rather than popular vote.
That said, I absolutely agree that awareness and practice of cartograms is needed, as there are plenty of times when such geopolitical-agnostic granularity is needed. But it's not just a tradeoff in difficulty in production and design...cartograms are more abstract to the viewer, and the more geopolitical data that you fuzz over, the more you might as well just make a labeled bar chart...which also is an underused format these days, because very few people will want to decorate their articles and essays with bar charts when maps are just as easy to make.
[1] http://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/facebook-primary/ http://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/facebook-primary/
- Eridrus 11y agoI think labeled bar charts are worse than maps and cartograms for conveying coarser grained information. Bar charts beyond a single row are hard to compare because they use height rather than colour and they don't say anything about the location (e.g. I don't really know where wyoming is). They also don't say anything about population size, which is what this article is about. You could do some height + colour thing to get the same effect, but then you're just building a crappy cartogram.
- danso 11y ago> You could do some height + colour thing to get the same effect, but then you're just building a crappy cartogram. Yeah, that's what I meant. The spectrum for a cartogram has total geographical fidelity on one end, to total abstraction on the other. The latter would basically be a bar chart in which the geographical data has been basically ignored. On the more abstract side, the Guardian did a radial chart for U.S. gay rights...the positions around the circle corresponded roughly to regions, i.e. "Northeast" is the top-right of the circle. Of course, it has all the problems inherent to radial charts...but it's a nice example of something that could be a bar chart (a horizontal array of blocks) that attempted to include some geo-positioning data, even at a very general level: http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2012/may/10/data-visualisation-us-gay-rights http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2012/may/10/data-vi...
- jalammar 11y agoWhat about a horizontal bar chart (ordered by value)? Yes you'll have to scan the list to find Wyoming, but it would better relate how Wyoming compares to West Virginia (which seems to have almost the same size square in the cartogram).