4 ms·
What does having an ability to gain root access have to do with installing random malware apps? You can easily have a device with disabled root access and a cu
by izacus 11y ago
What does having an ability to gain root access have to do with installing random malware apps?
You can easily have a device with disabled root access and a curated store as a default and make gaining root access an added functionality (similarly how Android Nexus phones require you to issue a fastboot oem unlock command).
Where does this idea that the only alternative to not having some non-technical people install malware is to forbid root access to EVERYONE else?!
- newday 11y agoA large number of malware sites will walk you through side loading and bypassing your security to install their app which may be a compromised game or app like a Trojan. Not having this access is the only way to deal with this.
- izacus 11y agoNo it isn't. Just like random scammers leading people to give them money doesn't mean everyone should be banned from having a bank account or a credit card. Some minimal level of responsibility of action from a users side isn't unreasonable. Being locked out from your own hardware because there are a few uneducated users out there is absurd. Not to mention that now there are actually viruses and exploits out there that install themselves through security holes on users devices and the users can't remove them because they're locked out!
- raesene9 11y agoCare to provide some examples of iOS Viruses and exploits that install themselves and are un-removable due to restricted user experience? I have never seen any of those before.
- jhasse 11y agoNo problem: http://blog.binamuse.com/2014/09/coregraphics-memory-corruption.html http://blog.binamuse.com/2014/09/coregraphics-memory-corrupt... If you got an older iPhone, it's best not to open random PDFs anymore.
- raesene9 11y agoneat bug, although only the iPhone 4 and earlier would be unpatchable for it, and those devices are pretty much stuffed from a security standpoint anyway as they're vulnerable to the old DFU mode jailbreaks... I was kind of thinking more of examples of malware where people were actually using the lockdown of the OS to stop users removing it, but hey I said exploits and that's an exploit.
- jhasse 11y agoOn the other hand: Have you ever heard of examples of malware which told the use to root their phone? I think CyanogenMods solution, where root access has to be enabled in the Developer Settings, which have to be enabled by tapping the Android version number 6 times, is the perfect solution: My mum would stop immediately doing such a complicated thing if she wanted to install something.
- raesene9 11y agoI'm not sure I've seen one that told users to enable root, but from what I've seen of the android malware scene large parts of it rely on users installing software from non-Google sources and their lack of ability in discerning a good app. from malware. (one example of many http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/11/new-type-of-auto-rooting-android-adware-is-nearly-impossible-to-remove/ http://arstechnica.com/security/2015/11/new-type-of-auto-roo...) That seems to me to illustrate the point of a locked down environment fairly well...
- jhasse 11y agoAh I see. Let's hope Google is going to move the "install apps from 3rd party sources" switch to the Developer Settings in the future.
- newday 11y agoYes, actually. My ex, sister, and nephew all got bit. Wan't American netflix on your phone, do x, y and z. Want to play games free, just follow these simple steps. You're not seeing it because you probably have a good BS detector and google/research first. But they very much exist.
- beachstartup 11y agoit's because the demographic you're talking about is vanishingly small, and therefore apple does not care about it. do you notice them hurting for customers? i installed linux when i was 12. i've been working in this field for nearly 20 years. i'm abnormal, as 'techie' as they come, and i really just don't give a shit about having root access on my iphone. in fact i pretty much use it for a handful of things, primarily messaging, and that's it. i view my phone as a fancy microwave oven. from a business point of view, you might as well ask amazon for root access on their hypervisors, or network switches. some people give you that. others don't, because they just care about the people who want that.
- izacus 11y ago> it's because the demographic you're talking about is vanishingly small, and therefore apple does not care about it. do you notice them hurting for customers? How do you know?! There are billions of people out there not using Apple devices, how do you just claim that the demographic is vanishingly small? How did you measure it? Apple doesn't even own half of the market.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tommorris 11y agoApple would rather be profitable on 10% market share than unprofitable on a 90% market share.
- barnabee 11y agoI think it would be hard in practice to allow root access but limit it to people who know what they are doing and understand the risk. People will follow arbitrary instructions to modify settings and enter commands (that they don't understand) for the most trivial things and from the most untrusted groups (for example: to install pirated software, to customise their user interface, etc.), and will merrily click past every warning without reading it. As a result, there will be more malware if you even make enabling root access an option. It isn't surprising that Apple and others are happy just not catering to that small segment of the market.
- jkirsteins 11y ago> I think it would be hard in practice to allow root access but limit it This is largely solved, I think, by the current system. People who know/want/understand the risks, can have a rooted phone. But it is not trivial for the average layperson.