7 ms·
Ignore the GPS – That Ocean Is Not a Road
- sccxy 11y agoWhy advertise yourself as dumbass with zero common sense?
- thrownaway2424 11y agoArticle freely conflates GPS with software navigation. Over of these things works perfectly while the other has technical and usability quirks still not solved.
- Pxtl 11y agoThere's no need to be pedantic about that. GPS navigation Hardware and software branded itself as "GPS" for a long time, you can't blame the public and the media for conflating them now.
- pampa 11y agoThe real mystery is, why he even bothered to take a rental car from keflavik to his hotel in reykjavik, instead of just taking the shuttle.
- lolc 11y agoI was irritated by this, but I just accepted that "GPS" is what people call their devices and that's the name for the whole device.
- Pxtl 11y agoHonestly, it wouldn't hurt for the software to have some warnings and confirmations for trips that exceed 3 hours. I've been burned by this myself since I still used an old Garmin far past its expiry date - trying to avoid a border toll while I was visiting Buffalo, it tried to send me the complete wrong direction and I only stopped when I noticed the arrival time said 9am and not 9pm... I was unfamiliar with the area so it would be easy to not realize my mistake, I only checked the device when it became obvious when I'd been on the road too long for what was supposed to be a shortish drive. Similarly, in New Brunswick it tried to have me shortcut through an increasingly-rugged wasteland of logging roads. It took me an hour of backtracking to extricate myself from that. Fool me once, shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me. I use Google Maps now.
- pampa 11y agoI guess a GPS navigator is not an excuse for not having a map or not knowing how to read one, at least on longer out of town trips. I've been burned a number of times when a gps navigator tried to take a 'shorter route' through logging roads and mountain passes that you could cross only on foot.
- dk8996 11y agoI trusted Google Maps untill few weeks ago it sent us down a road that became undriveable and dangerous -- costing us about two hrs. Although, this did happen in Martinique, for the most part I've had good experiencea with Google Maps in US.
- ghaff 11y agoIn the Western US, there are a lot of roads that range between unpaved but well-graded and generally fine for passenger car use to serious high-clearance 4WD in good weather only. In my experience, Google Maps doesn't routinely send you down seriously questionable roads. But, if you drive around those areas, it behooves you to really understand the range of roads out there and be properly cautious rather than blindly depending on GPS--or, for that matter, a map. The biggest problem is really that a lot of people come from areas where road is 99% equivalent to passable by passenger car under most to all weather conditions and seasons. That's just not the case in many places, e.g. Death Valley.
- cgriswald 11y ago> If we’re being honest, it’s not that hard to imagine doing something similar ourselves. Most of us use GPS as a crutch while driving through unfamiliar terrain, tuning out and letting that soothing voice do the dirty work of navigating. It is very difficult for me to imagine driving 250 miles out of the way (especially when I'm tired and really want to get where I'm going); or driving into the ocean; or driving off a bridge because I've ignored all the road closed signs. I don't even shut my brain off to this degree when another human is helping navigate. The article is saying our cognitive maps are deteriorating because navigation software provides the information instantly at hand. For some people that may be true. I've noticed this effect in other aspects of my life, though not with navigation. But even if true, that does not explain people ignoring all other indicators that something is not correct.
- AJ007 11y agoThis sounds like a remix of one of the many "internet is making us dumb" stories. If anything the existence of GPS, satellite, constantly updated maps, and now detailed 3D city maps makes our "cognitive maps" (whatever that means) far better now than in the past where our navigation was done from printed Rand McNally folding map. The reality is there are a lot of impaired drivers on the road. May be they have been drinking, have early onset dementia, or just a mixture of prescription medications with undocumented side effects. A lot have spent half the time sending text messages on their phones. Whatever the circumstance, some of the tools we have now let them survive longer or at least pretend they know what they are doing.
- VLM 11y agoYou only listed impairments with no excuse that are socially unacceptable but done all the time by everyone and statistically usually ends well almost every time anyway. There's another class of impairment that make no interesting clickbait and no social signalling... Kid sick in the back seat or just naughty, unexpected construction reroute, dark, bad weather, digestive impairment or other sudden onset illness setting in, the purpose of the trip might be highly distracting (funeral, sick relative in hospital), crazy unanticipated traffic jams, maybe the car is mechanically starting to act up. Those stories make terrible clickbait unless there's a GPS involved, then the GPS can take 100% of the blame as if there was nothing else involved, and it makes itself insta-clickbait.
- desas 11y agoEveryone laughs at these mistakes, including me. Mine happened while holidaying in the Lake District, we were planning to hike to Scafell Pike (highest point in England), from Seathwaite. So we rolled out of our tent at 5am, got in the car, punched Seathwaite into the sat nav, and drove. We passed ominous warning signs. We thought that sounded reasonable for the highest point in England so we ploughed on. We did get out the car at Seathwaite an hour or more later, feeling slightly puzzled as we had recollections it was about 30 minutes away from the campground. We put it down to google underestimating the time taken to go on the slightly scary steep, single track roads. After stretching our legs, we consulted our actual map + walking instructions and couldn't get anything to match up. We flagged down a local and they pointed out that there's another Seathwaite about ten miles away as the crow flies and that was probably the one we wanted. The catch was that three mountains lay between us. I've rarely felt so embarrassed. The drive over the Wrynose and Hard Knott pass was very picturesque though.
- proactivesvcs 11y agoBack in the summer I found an oddity on the map what I wanted to explore for the sake of it. It was on the way back from a customer's house and I had the rest of the afternoon off, so it was great timing. I navigated the waypoints and tracks as the map directed but one of the track's surfaces was degenerating beyond practical travel. I didn't mind a bit of mud, but didn't feel like drowning :-) After another bend, it was clear the mud wasn't getting better. I turned round and headed back home, as the alternate routes weren't really practical. This story ends with not a lot happening. I find stories such as the headline, and others in the comments, are very difficult to relate to. I suppose this is because I take in information I see in real-time and allow myself to make decisions on the fly. I'm sure there's a part of the brain involved which must be inhibited in some way that allows blind following of instruction, be it made by a device or other way.
- mcarrano 11y agoLate last year a friend of mine was involved in a car accident. The other driver was following the Google Maps directions on their phone which told them to go down a one way street, it just happened to be the wrong direction. Luckily no one was hurt. People really need to pay attention when they drive and read the road signs. Just because the GPS says to go down a street, doesn't mean you are allowed to go down it the wrong way.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Piskvorrr 11y agoYup, source data is one of the issues here: I had Waze send me up one-way streets more than once. (Okay...there's a community map editor, let's fire that up and fix this. "You can't edit a road, you need Magic Editor Points." Oookay, how do I get Magic Editor Points? "You get points by making edits..." and you need points to do that. Well take that editor and shove it, I'm in no mood for a Catch-22.)
- rfreytag 11y agoWhile driving in Bavaria my wife was programming the GPS. Since she new nothing of umlauts (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umlaut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umlaut) we ended up going to a tiny farming community rather than a town near Schloß Neuschwanstein. Luckily, a suitable castle also constructed by King Ludwig can be found in nearly every part of Bavaria, a few minutes searching turned one up, and it turned into an unexpectedly wonderful day. GPS errors can bring good experiences as well.
- nsns 11y agoRelated: http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/aug/04/lourdes-gps-mistake-catholic-pilgrims http://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/aug/04/lourdes-gps-mis...
- ryanmcbride 11y agoThe only GPS mishap I've ever had was when Google maps got me in an infinite loop. I was driving into San Francisco from the East bay, and when I got over the bay bridge, Google had me get off the freeway, turn a few times, and I ended up right back on the freeway, going back over the bridge. I realized right away what was happening after I got back on the freeway, but there were no more exits, so I had to drive to treasure island, and turn around. That wasn't so bad, but once I crossed the bridge again, I kept following the GPS and ended up right back on the bridge. Google Maps would try to get me to do this every time I drove over the bridge for a couple of weeks, but I never fell for it again. This was around the time that they were building the new east bridge, so I wondered if it had anything to do with that but I can't imagine how it would.
- therein 11y agoI'm sure at least a portion of those construction workers on the bridge had Android phones that Google collected maps data from.
- chinathrow 11y agoHa, then someone just needs a flock of location enabled smartphones pushing faked traffic patterns back to Google and hilarity ensues... :)
- merpnderp 11y agoComing off the bridge out of Galveston, Google Maps has put me in an infinite loop before. No construction to blame either.
- shadeless 11y agoThis reminds me of a trip I was on a couple of years ago. I was traveling from Italy to France, and wanted to make a visit to a friend in Switzerland on the way. I never drove that route before, so I just typed the friend's address into the GPS and followed every turn. It made me go on a really curvy and steep road up the Alps, than equally curvy and steep down. The road was wet from the melting ice/snow (it was a summer trip) and at one point I went through a foggy area which looked like I was driving through the clouds. It was a pretty interesting experience, but I kept thinking that it was strange that there were basically no other cars in either direction. When I got to the bottom I saw why: this road was merging with a tunnel which goes directly underneath the path I took, saving you a couple of hours of driving. Live and learn.
- JorgeGT 11y agoSo the GPS took you into a lonesome journey of introspection, man and machine conquering a demanding road through the beautiful scenery of the summer Alps... instead of directing you to through a boring, overcrowded tunnel? Seems pretty good to me!
- Zigurd 11y agoI have a good counter-example. I was traveling to Shenzhen and I had a faxed address and directions for the hotel. It was in Chinese, which I can't read. About an hour into what should have been a 20 minute trip, it occurred to me I was being taken somewhere entirely different. I turned on data roaming, figuring that could not be more expensive than ending up two hours away from my hotel at 3am. A search in English turned up local results with labels in Chinese. The driver had to drop me at the taxi garage to wait for a driver going in the right direction, so I got to see what a Chinese taxi company looks like at 2am, but was spared a lengthier adventure.
- Piskvorrr 11y agoWell look what the cat brought in :D https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-xta1/t31.0-8/fr/cp0/e15/q65/12694731_10207803332897022_8128739970234650151_o.jpg?efg=eyJpIjoidCJ9 https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-xta1/t31.0...
- njharman 11y agoHow many people got lost and died or whatever before GPS navigation? How many people have been lost in dangerous situation but were able to get to safety due to GPS navigation? How many people are balls stupid and will win a Darwin Award regardless of what technology the use or don't.
- kbart 11y agoExactly. There were and always will be stupid people, it's not technologies to blame. If not blindly following GPS to death, they would choke on spoon or smth anyway. I'm actually glad to see that natural selection works even in the digital age.
- __bb 11y agoI have anecdata here. A single lane, paved but rough road, signed 'no entry for deliveries' regularly has delivery vehicles coming up it because their GPS navigator told them to. The sign is large. The track is almost half a mile long and has nowhere to turn around at the end. It is very difficult to get the navigation providers to remove this private access from the maps. Even if they do, there are many people who will never update their satnav software. This lack of updating may become an increasing problem as roads change and hardware ages, but directions remain the same.
- YZF 11y agoReminds me of a time when I was using GPS to get around Vancouver Island. Rather than taking me on the real highway I got directed to a "highway" that was a narrow mountain logging road. I did realize exactly what was going on and decided to keep going in my Subaru Outback for the sake of the adventure. Eventually did get through. Then there was this time in Utah where my GPS decided that following the powerlines on what was sometimes not even a road was better than going around. One of the locals hearing the story later joked you should never use a GPS in Utah. In both cases I knew the GPS was crazy but as long as I could safely continue I went on for the sake of the adventure... If things got too hairy I'd simply turn around...
- aaron695 11y agoI remember in Lebanon getting on the wrong bus with a slightly similar name and ended up somewhere I wasn't supposed to be. Dam GPS, these days I would have realised sooner and not had that adventure.
- ars 11y agoSelf Driving cars rely on exactly this same data. (Read all the stories from other HN members in this thread on bad data, it's not always the user's fault.) Despite all the hype I don't expect general purpose self driving cars ever. At best we'll have some interstate express lanes exclusively designed for self driving cars, and that's about it.
- ghaff 11y ago"Ever" is a long time. Though I agree insofar as it's probably further out than a lot of people are assuming. But, yes, it will be a long time before maps are sufficiently good across wide areas of the rural US (much less the world as a whole) to enable self-driving. The situation when you start talking about unpaved roads becomes even more problematic.
- anon4 11y agoIsn't it just a matter of the car paying attention to the road and if it doesn't match up to the map's version, picking an alternate route?
- ghaff 11y agoAutonomous vehicles today are highly dependent on having accurate high-resolution road maps. Without them, you don't have a self-driving car. And, when you talk about unpaved rural roads, there often aren't any alternative routes. Presumably if/when we get such vehicles, they'll only be approved to drive some subset of roads and, if they encounter an unknown condition, they'll have to stop and have a human driver take over in some manner.
- korginator 11y agoAn even more troubling aspect is the increasing lack of ability for our pilots to fly by hand instead of relying on the autopilot. A large number of accidents today, like the Asiana 214 that went into the SFO airport sea wall, could easily be avoided if either the PIC or the FO pay attention to what's happening around them instead of having their eyes glued to the colorful shiny dials. Take Asiana 214 - the PIC had pulled engine power to idle, flew far too low on his approach to runway 28L, expected automation to pick up slack, didn't bother to visually check if things were all right, and crashed into the sea wall.
- lolc 11y agoLots of People rely on GPS navigation without checking. This tells us how well it works and nothing else. As an OSM-editor I know the map has many errors. (Not in my neighborhood mind you.) So when I strapped a Garmin loaded with OSM to my bicycle I knew what to expect. Sometimes I let it navigate my destination even when I know the route I want to take. Then I watch the device give me suggestions to know whether the map works. Found quite a few details that break navigation in OSM. Used that way you get immune to the urge to follow everything the device tells you. I have yet to attempt cycling down stairs that were recorded as path. One common occurrence is the device insisting on you to turn around; its estimates getting longer and longer. A few later villages later in your journey you cross the nodes where the road was not correctly connected in OSM and the device is suddenly happy again. When I'm somewhere I don't know, and OSM is reliable in that area, I find navigation very comfortable to use and it's saved me a lot of brain cycles.