4 ms·
If you're looking to strike a balance, there also needs to be a good-faith effort to make the work available to the public domain after the copyright term expir
by mindslight 11y ago
If you're looking to strike a balance, there also needs to be a good-faith effort to make the work available to the public domain after the copyright term expires.
For software, the original creative work (source code) should need to be escrowed. And the same for any work obfuscated with DRM.
- jdbernard 11y agoI disagree. I do not think there should be an obligation for a creator to give away their work after the copyright expires. They just no longer get the benefit of having a legal mechanism to prevent others from copying/using it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 11y agoAnd what does the public get from granting you this temporary monopoly?
- jdbernard 11y agoLet's look at music for an example. Copyright provides a period in which they original artist had control over how the work is handled commercially. After the copyright expires the original artist can no longer use the law to prevent other people from redistributing or reproducing the work. However, the artist has no obligation to release the studio masters. Copyright makes it more viable for the creator to actually make a moving from their work. So to answer your question, the public is encouraging creative work. In the case of software, the work itself would no longer be protected from reproduction or duplication by others, but there is no obligation for the original creator to facilitate the reproduction by others.
- mindslight 11y ago> So to answer your question, the public is encouraging creative work Creative work which the public has no access to even after the limited monopoly period is up.
- jdbernard 11y agoThat's not at all true. People have access to the work by virtue of owning copies of it. Music can be played. Software can be reverse-engineered or just copied. Artwork can be copied. The ideas which are the core unique value of creative work are already out in the world by virtue of the work being seen and handled by the public. Copyright exists to provide the creator protection so that they can release their creation to the world without fear of it being immediately devalued by duplication. Without copyright I don't want to release my new idea, I want to keep it secret and charge people ridiculous amounts to have access. Society has never demanded people hand over their work without compensation. Copyright is not at all about handing over the source of your works. Copyright is about artificially preventing other people from duplicating your work for a period of time. When that time expires, others are allowed to reproduce your work, but you are not required to hand over your sources. When a carpenter makes a chair he can claim copyright on the design of the chair. During the time that his design is under copyright nobody else is allowed to make chairs that are obviously copied or derived from his design. When the copyright expires the design is no longer protected, but nobody goes to the original carpenter to confiscate his inventory and release it to the public, nor to appropriate his designs. Those are his. He still owns the designs. They are just no longer protected by law from duplication.
- mindslight 11y agoDRM directly destroys this "ownership" you speak of. There is no long-term access to a work that expects to phone home on every use. You seem to be coming from the baseless framework of imaginary property wherein creation of property rights is a bona fide good thing, regardless of whether they're congruent with the underlying physics. However, the base law of this jungle is that copying is easy, creators have DRM, and the public has VHS and P2P. Copyright is justified by the framework of a tradeoff whereby the naturally-existing public domain is retarded in order to encourage the creation of more works that will enter it at a later time. You still haven't directly addressed why the public should agree to restrict itself from copying media, only for the copyright owner to renege on their contribution when the monopoly period is up.