3 ms·
I think it's mostly about brand security. If a battery works with the laptop, it's guaranteed to be a tested compatible one. Quickly slapping up a counterfeit
by nine_k 11y ago
I think it's mostly about brand security.
If a battery works with the laptop, it's guaranteed to be a tested compatible one. Quickly slapping up a counterfeit and selling it as a brand-name thing won't work.
A battery ua a critical device, prone to fires or blasts if made improperly. One such incident would significantly tarnish the brand. Thus the over-reaction.
I wish there wad an open spec for certified batteries, to allow for third-party fixes and replacements, though.
- martinald 11y agoAgreed. As we've seen from. The USB typeC stuff, seriously screwing power cables and batteries is really bad. If you put a crap SD card in a laptop it might be the wrong size. If you put a bad counterfit battery in and it explodes and permanently disfigures someone you've got a PR nightmare before people have figured out the real reason.
- Klathmon 11y agoEspecially today when a single tweet can spark that PR nightmare and social media sites will take a title and run with it without ever doing any fact checking. If i were lenovo, i'd be doing the same exact thing, and i'm honestly surprised we don't see more of this stuff in things like cables, chargers, etc...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Fice 11y ago> Quickly slapping up a counterfeit and selling it as a brand-name thing won't work. Wouldn't it be enough to just display an UEFI boot message to notify users when non-original battery is detected?
- yoshamano 11y agoNot when brand security is your concern. A user could put a Lo Pan Six Demon Bag battery in their laptop and then it bursts into flames. The user is going to complain that their Lenovo laptop burst into flames. Everyone else is going to parrot that statement because almost no one looks into anything anymore. Once someone does dig into it and find out that it was actually the shoddy Lo Pan battery, its too late. "Lenovo" and "third degree burns" has been plastered all over the Internet and good luck finding Lo Pan to hold him accountable.
- qb45 11y ago> One such incident would significantly tarnish the brand. Ahem, as if there were no reported cases of genuine Apple/Dell/HP/Sony/... batteries catching fire. Seems all those significantly tarnished brands are doing quite fine. edit: Or... how about Lenovo? http://www.cpsc.gov/en/Recalls/2015/Lenovo-Expands-Recall-of-Battery-Packs-for-ThinkPad-Notebook-Computers/ http://www.cpsc.gov/en/Recalls/2015/Lenovo-Expands-Recall-of...
- pyre 11y agoIt's one thing to shoot yourself in the foot, it's another thing entirely to go down for someone else's screw-up.
- reirob 11y agoBy applying this logic a computer manufacturer should not allow any non certified OS to run on their machines. Writing this on a ThinkPad running Linux. If this comes true I will stop buying Lenovo products. Until today I continue buying ThinkPads because their Linux support is among the best - and for the trackpoint and a good keyboard. But I definitely do not like how they behave lately. I am watching very closely for alternatives, every time I or any of people I know need to buy a new computer. As soon as the brand security will become more important as the requirements of their customers I will jump off the brand. A brand without customers is not worth anything.
- bad_user 11y agoWhy stop at the OS? They shouldn't allow non-certified apps either. Oh wait...
- superuser2 11y agoNo it doesn't, because a non-certified OS can at worst fail to work as expected. A DIY battery can send you to the burn ward.
- bbradley406 11y agoThere was a thread[1] recently in which a Linux (specifically systemd) bug was capable of bricking motherboards. ACPI bugs can cause overheating, failure to enter sleep mode, etc. In a perfect world of open source firmware this wouldn't be an issue, but until then the cover-your-ass behavior makes sense. Does the cost of replacing a few bricked machines outweigh the reputation cost? Probably not, but it's easy to understand the liability issues that arise from non certified OS's. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11008449 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11008449
- voltagex_ 11y agoThe way I see it the firmware has been implemented incorrectly - I don't think there's anything in the spec but shouldn't clearing all values == a reset to default, not a non-booting device?