5 ms·
Artificial intelligence could leave half the world unemployed
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>> “Humanity is about to face perhaps its greatest challenge ever, which is finding meaning in life after the end of ‘in the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread’,” he said. “We need to rise to the occasion and meet this challenge.” In the past that wasn't a problem. I'm thinking of classical Greece where the majority of the work was done by slaves and free citizens were, well, free, to better themselves. The result was an unprecedented flourishing of the arts, science and philosophy and basically the birth of the western civilisation. In later periods, the Rennaissance, the Industrial era and so on, there was also great progress in the sciences and also in political philosophy, and this was achieved by people who didn't have to labour in the fields for a living. So there should be no question that humanity is indeed able to better itself once it's relieved by the need to toil everyday to sustain itself. The real question is: will increased automation really mean a high enough standard of living for everyone? So far, automation just means that the work that is done by humans is less fulfilling, rather than more: macjobs, call centers, warehouse work, retail... hardly intellectually rewarding work. Instead, that kind of work crushes your spirit and leaves you no time or energy to pursue your interests and educate yourself or even exercise your body to improve your health. I do believe there is cause for concern. My concern is that in the future, the majority of work will be menial, meaningless, unproductive tasks where the human worker is just a cog in a huge automated machine of which he or she has no control. I fear we'll just become a lesser, less well paid kind of mindless drone, alongside our wonderful machines. And as to those machines I think the big risk is not that automation will become better than humans at doing jobs. The real risk is that automation will reach a mediocre level, even possibly a very low level of competence, but it will be employed anyway because of its competitive pricing. In other words, I see it as very plausible that even today's experts will be slowly replaced by incompetent, inexpert machines that will do the work that humans do today, for much less money and at a much lower standard. If we're ever so dumb as to hand over our future to our machines, at least the ones we have now, the end result will be misery and unhappiness for all.
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y agoNow, about our wondrous machines and algorithms. This needs a different comment. >> Selman, a professor at Cornell University, said: “Computers are basically starting to hear and see the way humans do,” thanks to advances in big data and “deep learning”. I'm a student of AI. I'm studying for an MSc in Intelligent Systems at the University of Sussex in the UK. I come from a classical AI background, with studies in discrete maths, logic and logic programming in particular. I've studied machine learning and to a lesser extent neural networks. I'm familiar with deep learning. This limited knowledge nevertheless gives me the stenght of conviction to say that, no- the quoted comment is not a good representation of the state of the art. AI systems are still far from perceiving the world in "the way humans do". Machine learning is a powerful tool, but it has severe limitations. Deep learning is certainly not magic and neural networks in general are "just" optimisation (except we're optimising systems of functions). I really don't see how any technique that we have at this point in time can be used to produce machines with anything approaching human levels of competence in the complex tasks that humans are good at. Sure, we have machines that can drive cars or play Chess or Go competently. However, those are very clearly delineated tasks. Chess and Go are games with well-known rules in a restricted domain. Driving is also a clearly strictly defined domain - for instance, you won't see Google car driving offroad; my theory is that if there's no roads or signs to guide it it would not be able to navigate on its own. I might be wrong on that. The important thing is that although machine learning algorithms can be trained on any conceivable task, and the same algorithm can often be trained on a large variety of tasks, changing tasks requires new training. This training requires resources that scale, very often exponentially so, with the complexity of the task. Training a Chess-playing AI requires a lot of data and computational power. Training a Go-playing AI requires a lot of different data and another lenghty period of training. For a game where not enough data is available, it would be difficult to obtain good results from machine learning. Machine learning itself has not given the best results in competitive AI. Humans on the other hand excel at generalising from very few examples and can often pick up a new task with minimal training. For instance, from playing football to playing basketball, or from playing Magic: the Gathering to playing Poker. We excel in very different types of tasks: competitive tasks, collaborative tasks, games, survival, commerce, anything you can think of. I don't see how machine learning will ever be able to accomplish such feats, no matter how competent individual algorithms can become in specific tasks.