3 ms·
I've never smoked cigarettes but cigars I have. They make so many claims about how addictive nicotine is, and yet cigars are supposed to have so much more nicot
by giancarlostoro 11y ago
I've never smoked cigarettes but cigars I have. They make so many claims about how addictive nicotine is, and yet cigars are supposed to have so much more nicotine than cigarettes, here I am a year without smoking a cigar (maybe I've had one or two in the past year, if anything) and I'm probably not going through what a cigarette smoker goes through, and I've gone times where I've had a cigar daily. Winston Churchill smoked daily and lived to be around 90. So I'm not an "expert" but a lot of what they say doesn't add up with what I've lived and it seems others have lived. Cigarettes aren't pure tobacco usually anyway, they're full of "tobacco sheets", just like Coca Cola isn't as full of sugar as it is "Corn Syrup." My uncle on the other hand smokes daily for quite a few years, and I never see him have the same symptoms other cigarette smokers usually do. The trick is probably the fact we don't inhale the cigar smoke into our lungs, enough of the smoke will get in there regardless.
- spdionis 11y agoIn my opinion he addiction doesn't come from nicotine but from the act itself which is very relaxing and pleasant. Btw even if you don't inhale I understand that nicotine gets in your system anyway. Probably in smaller quantities, which is offset by the high amount of nicotine in cigar/pipe tobacco.
- giancarlostoro 11y agoI do it socially really, but again, it's been a year or so since.
- anexprogrammer 11y agoThe psychological aspects are habit forming; the social aspects, the ritual etc. Whilst nicotine is undoubtedly addictive, there are other things in tobacco / cigarettes that seem far more addictive. There's also the additional crap added, like chemicals to ensure the cigarette doesn't go out like hand rolled and cigars do, etc. The part I missed most whilst quitting, with the aid of vaping (nicotine replacement gums, patches and inhalers were a waste of time and money for me) was something present in tobacco, but not in ecigs. Vaping never quite replaced that, or felt as nice. The occasional cig I had when out drinking with friends made it quite tempting to relapse - though I didn't. The nicotine withdrawal when I quit vaping was so minor compared to the withdrawal from stopping tobacco that I actually wonder if the various quitting aids are replacing the wrong chemical(s). I am, of course, just an anecdotal data point of one.
- cronjobber 11y agoI'm currently witnessing an e-cig based quitting attempt that confirms your story. Just as in your experience, gums and patches tried earlier had been a total waste; and likewise, unlimited nicotine on demand does not seem to capture the full addictive content of cigarette smoking.
- zepto 11y agoThis undermines much of what you've said. The addictive properties of nicotine have been well studied. The 'pleasantness' associated with smoking is mostly caused by the relief of the need for nicotine.
- cronjobber 11y agoPart of it probably is stimulus-response psychology. Cigarette smokers usually pair smoking with a lot more different situations than cigar smokers. As a consequence, the smoking impulse becomes more easily generalized for cigarette smokers, while cigar smokers restrict smoking to a stable, limited set of occasions.
- dghughes 11y agoAn Engineer Guy video on YouTube where discusses the invention of the industrial cigarette rolling machine indirectly answer that question. https://youtu.be/_4zbNJmtbGo?t=51 https://youtu.be/_4zbNJmtbGo?t=51 The short version is cigarette smoke is inhaled pipe and cigar more or less just in the mouth. The nicotine in the smoke in the lungs is rapidly absorbed into the blood which goes to the brain in seconds.
- DanBC 11y agoone a day isn't enough to form a strong habit. Try 20 a day, or 60 a day to see what a strong habit is actually like. And smoking cigars is still pretty harmful, with heavily increased risk of some cancers of the mouth and throat.