4 ms·
Why not just deliver nicotine?
by mirimir 11y ago
Why not just deliver nicotine?
- spdionis 11y agoBecause it's 90% not about the nicotine.
- mirimir 11y agoI smoked for many years. And yes, there was a lot more to it than the nicotine. The aroma of a good Turkish/Virginia blend. The habitual mechanics of it all. But when it came down to giving it up, it was all about the nicotine. Also, I still miss the attention-focusing effects of nicotine. But it's not worth the addiction.
- bbarn 11y agoGums. Patches. Lozenges. We've had methods of doing just that for decades, and none have had the rampant adoption e-cigarettes have. The short answer is there's a lot more to smoking than nicotine. Social interactions, rituals, etc that the vaping still allows for.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoBecause smokers aren't nicotine addicts like heroin users are heroin addicts. One of the big effects of nicotine is that it reinforces habit formation. Smokers have a giant pile of situations where the unthinkingly obvious thing to do is to pull out a cigarette and start smoking it. Reprogramming the brain by replacing the action with "pull out an e-cig and start vaping" is much easier to do than not having a thing to do. If you don't have something else to replace the act with, you're probably going to do something like "think about how much you want a cigarette"
- mirimir 11y agoMy underlying point, which I should have made explicit, was that adding all those extra components to e-cigs was a risk. Arguably an unnecessary risk. Except for marketing, of course. Experimentally, it appears that GRAS by oral route doesn't necessarily mean that vaping is safe. But that's not very surprising. Vaping does involve heat, after all. Not burning, but perhaps high enough temperatures for components to react and degrade. Also, GRAS doesn't really mean "safe". It means that people have been using something forever, and it's not acutely toxic. So inertia and vested interests win. Vaping just glycerin and nicotine would arguably be a lot safer, no?
- rdancer 11y agoIt is counter-intuitive, but smoking is more effective a mechanism of delivery than intravenous injection. It gives you the biggest hit the fastest. And everything else is way, way slower and mellower.