6 ms·
Horses recognise human emotions
- MPSimmons 11y agoThat would make them the second animal known to do this. (http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2015/02/150212-dogs-human-emotion-happy-angry-animals-science/ http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2015/02/150212-dogs-...) Probably not a coincidence that they're also one of the relatively few domesticated animals (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_domesticated_animals https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_domesticated_animals).
- mrob 11y agoFor a long time I thought of horses as basically cows you can ride. Then I saw a video of a horse playing with a giant ball: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=emxI-nRGWBE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=emxI-nRGWBE It's acting more like a dog than a cow. And there are many other videos of horses playing and doing tricks like dogs can. My opinion of horses greatly improved. Thinking about it, I shouldn't have found it surprising. Horses are herd/pack animals like dogs, so they naturally have social skills, and despite being herbivores they are still mammals, so their body language is at least somewhat similar to humans. And also like dogs, horses have been domesticated to work closely with humans. Most other domesticated animals are either solitary, or not required to work directly with humans. I think any domesticated mammal with both those properties will likely read human emotions. Even though the dog has the advantage of being a carnivore so it is more similar to humans, and being required to work more independently than the horse, putting more selection pressure on its communication skills, the horse still far exceeds popular animals like the cat in its ability to communicate with humans. If the dog is "man's best friend", I think the horse can be "man's second best friend".
- jjtheblunt 11y agoThere are plenty of videos of cows also playing with balls and with others. Not kidding. Look for The Gentle Barn and Dudley the cow, for one example.
- mrob 11y agoDudley looks a little smarter and more active than cows I see locally, but not nearly as much as a horse. Most of his "playing" looks more like scratching/rubbing type behavior, the same as you see with motorized cow brushes.
- PerfectElement 11y agoDon't say that! How are we supposed to enjoy our burgers now?
- Animats 11y agoHorses have a moderately wide intelligence range. At the low end, they're down around the cow level. At the high end, they're well into the dog range. The hot-blooded breeds (Arabs and Thoroughbreds) seem to be smarter, but that may be because they're more active and more likely to initiate activity.
- codezero 11y agoFor some interesting history on animal behavior check this out. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clever_Hans https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clever_Hans
- dmckeon 11y ago"One person presents the photo while another holds the horse," Indeed. One wonders if the person holding the horse and the person presenting the face photos could see if the photo was of an angry or other face.
- Phemist 11y agoFrom the article: Experimenters were blind to the stimulus in 82% of trials and analyses showed no difference in subject responses according to this factor (see the electronic supplementary material tables SII and SIII). So, it didn't even matter. Pretty much everyone that would be doing research of this sort is familiar with Clever Hans, so I'm sure they'd be extra careful when designing their experiment.
- bcg1 11y agoThis study should be expanded to include wild horses. Also if they could somehow measure "positive" reactions that would be interesting. Domesticated horses are generally trained through fear; it is not surprising they react to angry faces. So it might also be interesting to conduct this same test on horses trained only with positive reinforcement techniques.
- qjighap 11y agoI live in a rural community. I have had many friends and family work with our local light-horse association. I would really appreciate you localizing that comment about trained through fear and reporting it to your local equestrian society. I apologize if you are not from North America and part of a country that allows you do so.
- Animats 11y agoOf course horses can recognize some human emotions. Most humans, even ones who handle horses, can't read horse emotions well. Horses are quite expressive, but their body language is alien. Horse facial expressions exist, but involve very quick eye movements, something discovered only about twenty years ago. Most of the bigger horse expressions are in ears, lips, tail, and carriage. If horses don't get feedback from their humans indicating some understanding on the human side, they often stop trying to communicate. To learn how horses communicate, watch them in an open field for long periods. There are frequent subtle dominance displays. Not kicking, or even ears pinned back; often it's just slightly narrowed eyes and an eye-flick, and one horse will yield space to another. If a horse does that to you, putting hands on hips and giving the horse a hard stare says that you got the message and aren't backing down. Most horses get this. It's a compromise between horse body language and human body language; a pidgin, if you will. Horses recognize eye contact. You're much less likely to be bitten, even by a hostile horse, if you're looking at the horse's eye and they're looking at you. It's quite possible to "speak horse" that way. "Talking with Horses", by Henry Blake, is useful. Whether or not a horse understands human to human expressions depends on how much experience they have with humans. It's a second language for horses, after all. Horses that live in herd situations deal mostly with other horses, and may not be that attuned to humans. Ones in stall situations tend to be more people-oriented, by necessity. The parent article was about horses that deal with lots of different people, so they're likely to have figured out human expressions.
- kr4 11y agothese are baby steps by our modern science to eventually come to the same conclusion that eastern traditions (Indian et al) have been maintaining since antiquity that the physical body is separate from the conscious [0], and the former is just a vehicle for a bound consciousness that actually goes through evolution (Vedas state that there are 8.4 milions kinds of species that a soul takes birth into), before finally becoming a human. The birth as human is considered special for the consciousness because it signifies evolution of intellect/wisdom sheath wich in simple terms means that bound consciousness has attained free will. It can now evolve further and can even become free from bondage that is, repeated cycles of birth&death by following one of systematic, proven paths to attain self-realization. >>> An activated fourth sheath is what distinguishes human beings from animals. Only humans have the ability to direct their own lives, free from the promptings of instinct, and to make moral choices. The sages considered the development of a healthy vijnanamaya kosha so important that they placed the exercises for it at the very beginning of the yoga system. These are the yamas and niyamas, commitments every yoga student is asked to make: not to harm, lie, steal, overindulge, or desire more than you actually need; instead you are asked to be content, pure, self-disciplined, studious, and devoted. 0: https://yogainternational.com/article/view/the-koshas-5-layers-of-being https://yogainternational.com/article/view/the-koshas-5-laye... 1: http://www.swamij.com/koshas.htm http://www.swamij.com/koshas.htm
- Mouq 11y agoYou realize that the idea of consciousness separate from the body is extremely popular in Western traditions as well? Much Christian theology, for example, is pretty fundamentally reliant on the idea of the soul.
- dang 11y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11097193 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11097193 and marked it off-topic.
- finishingmove 11y agoMy completely unscientific opinion, coming from my own observations, is that animals are generally much more emphatic than we give them credit for.
- klibertp 11y ago> animals are generally much more emphatic than we give them credit for. They're also frequently much more emphatic than people I mostly work with as a programmer. ;-) No, really: I own two cats now, and I grew up with dogs, cats, horses and goats around and it led me to believe that animals generally do dream, do have emotions and are generally able to understand or feel emotions of others. They also do think, they do try to predict the future, and they do learn on their own, sometimes frighteningly quickly. But it's convenient to believe otherwise and even people who should know better tend to forget about it during the meals. Just try to imagine how eating a burger would feel with a thought like: "ok, now I'm eating something that was smarter and more emotional than my 2yo niece".
- veddox 11y agoAs a biology student I can tell you that you are most likely correct :-) Behavioural studies in animals are a fascinating field. I can't back it up with citations right now, but I'm pretty sure horses and dogs are not the only animals to read human facial expressions. Chimps, cats, parrots - you name it - if it's been in close contact with humans for any length of time, I wouldn't be surprised if it learnt how to read our emotions.