3 ms·
My hope would be the supervisors for The Mission district as well as Chinatown in SF would read this and take notice. But... given their politics, even if they
by mc32 11y ago
My hope would be the supervisors for The Mission district as well as Chinatown in SF would read this and take notice. But... given their politics, even if they came to understand it, I don't think they'd come around on this, to the detriment of those they purport to represent.
The politics in SF are weird. Many politicians do superficially irrational things --they look good on the surface, but in effect they are detrimental. On the bright side, the mayors themselves have been rational about attracting business and bringing in development.
If you listen to KQED and their local reporters, it's like they'd like to have SF frozen in time in 1992. As if they'd rather it go down the way of Detroit rather than it become an economic center on the Pacific with the effects they bring ("gentrification" population moves, etc.) They want to eat their cake and have it too. And I understand it. It's very attractive. Let's have a great economy BUT let's have it so all other things stay the same, no disruption, no changes to neighborhoods, etc. Not even China can pull that off. Especially when SF proper is all but 49sq mi. But if we will it that way hard enough...
- rmason 11y agoI do not think that San Francisco can in any way be compared to the decline of Detroit. Poor civic planning, racism and the loss of jobs to non-union Southern plants all paid a part in Detroit's population dropping by two thirds over a fifty year span. I read a great book over Christmas, Once in a great city by David Maraniss, which covered Detroit at its peak from 1962-1964. Wayne State actually pretty accurately predicted the city's future then but the report was ignored by those in a position to stem its decline.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mc32 11y agoYou're right, it's not the same. Detroit is a remarkable exception. But, SF in the late 80's early 90's was not a place you might think would grow. People were leaving the city for other bay area cities. Labor intensive industries were leaving [bedding for one] SOMA, Tenderloin, Market were severely depressed areas. And companies can go --just like they left Detroit; just like they left SF in the late 80s early 90s.
- xivzgrev 11y agoI thought the article was weak. There was barely a change in displacement with new market rate housing vs not. My biggest issue is the highway theory - build more lanes, commute time is shorter, more people drive, purpose defeated. Here build more market rate housing, prices fall, more people move in that would have loved elesewhere in bay area, prices rise. Purpose defeated. I like projects that include percentage of units to be affordable, rent control, and programs to build on surplus public land for affordable housing. Beyond that not sure what else they can do. At end of day government only has so much they can subsidize. Unless they start building homes underground or on the bay...
- mc32 11y agoThe thing is the people who can afford to buy a house or pay the high rents will push out the people who can't, regardless of housing stock. Someone with money can buy the unit I rent, and, given it's private property there is no reason in the world they should not be able to move in --we're not at the stage of confiscating property. Traffic throughput is different [unless you are comparing it to the toll express lanes]. Normal highways have no barrier to entry other than the vehicle you need to enter with anyway, so of course people will take whichever way gets you there faster. If before you had to take the 2-hour bus, or the surface streets which took two hours, but now you can take the freeway which takes an hour, all things being equal you take the freeway... Now, if you had to pay a toll to get on the freeway AND there was also public transit which was cheaper, you might take public transit. The sad thing is politicians on either side ignore economics when it benefits their point of view or it aligns themselves with the ignorance of the people they represent [climate change, fiscal policy, housing, jobs policies, etc] so I'm under no illusions this report by the state gov't[1] will convince city supes. [1]http://www.lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/3345 http://www.lao.ca.gov/Publications/Report/3345
- jacobolus 11y agoI wish the Mission activists would spend some effort teaming up with http://www.spur.org http://www.spur.org and similar organizations to promote improved zoning and housing development in other SF neighborhoods, e.g. the Richmond/Sunset/Parkside, which consist nearly exclusively of single family houses, and waste tremendous amounts of space on wide streets with massive amounts of street parking. Turning a few more streets in those neighborhoods into mixed-use commercial corridors or even denser (3–6 story) residential could add a huge amount of housing stock to the city. (Not to mention advocating for more housing development in the peninsula and south bay, where the worst employment/housing imbalances are.)
- eli_gottlieb 11y ago>If you listen to KQED and their local reporters, it's like they'd like to have SF frozen in time in 1992. It's like? I thought that was exactly what they wanted.