7 ms·
Politicians don't get educated. They get bought. Do you have as much money as copyright industry? No? Then, no, you can't have your sensible laws. You'll have t
by scotty79 11y ago
Politicians don't get educated. They get bought. Do you have as much money as copyright industry? No? Then, no, you can't have your sensible laws. You'll have theirs. The only action you can take is to ignore those unenforcible.
- Buttons840 11y agoSeems like this is the real problem we should use technology to solve. How can we make it more expensive to buy politicians?
- eric-hu 11y agoAndroid politicians with a high buyoff feature.
- Buttons840 11y agoMaybe. :) But seriously. Starting idea: Build a website that does some well analytics and makes it clear when politicians chose profit and special interests over the good of the people. I know some sites do this, but I haven't seen any executed well enough to reach the right people.
- briandear 11y agoReally 'good of the people' is a very dangerous concept. And what exactly is a special interest? People interested in copyright reform is a special interest just as people interested in copyright preservation is a special interest. Lenin was obstesibly starting a revolution for the 'good of the people.' Cuba did as well.. The good of the people there has resulted in an average monthly income of $20. Don't knock the special interests.. EFF and Wiki are both examples of special interests just as much as the special interests of the publishing industry. The book Economics in One Lesson is certainly worth reading..
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoSpecial interests are definitely the problem, specifically when they're asymmetrical. Disney owns more television stations and has more money than the EFF.
- scotty79 11y agoYou could make politicians ban lobbying and private funding of political campaigns! Oh, wait...
- i573323 11y ago“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it.”
- 4bpp 11y agoIt is fairly self-evident that we can't get purely self-interested and sufficiently coordinated with anyone who could displace them from their positions (in the sense that they value keeping their own bribes over denying their opponents bribes) politicians to support any measure that would actually make them no longer receive bribes. If one of the two assumptions above fails: assuming we can legally define what exactly constitutes a bribe (and I imagine this is not a solved problem), it probably would be possible to pass a law that says that if you can prove as a politican that you were offered or given a bribe (for a sum n), the bribe-offering party gets fined (say) 100n (aiming for their economic destruction), of which 5n is given to you (thus incentivising you to report bribes) and some token amount is given to everyone else serving in the same elected body as you (to incentivise everyone to vote for the law).
- Bjartr 11y agoThe potential problem is that now you've created one of those loophole things. Now publically bribe the official n/105 of what you actually want, and it's totally legal!
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> The potential problem is that now you've created one of those loophole things. Now publically bribe the official n/105 of what you actually want, and it's totally legal! That would still reduce the influence by >95% because you have to pay 105x and the politician only gets 5x. The actual problem is that if a politician is known for reporting bribes then they won't be offered any, so taking 1x every time is still more profitable than taking 5x once.
- 4bpp 11y agoWell, if the law is set up in such a fashion that you can "keep receipts" and report retroactively to enjoy the full benefits, you would still have an incentive to dredge everything up the moment you retire (and put the extra 4x lifetime bribe earnings into your retirement fund or bequeath them to your kids), and while the crackdown would be delayed, the bribing parties would still eventually come under the hammer (so unless there is some way for them to take and run with their short-term earnings leaving a shell company to be punished, there would not be an incentive for them to bribe in the first place).
- vpkaihla 11y agoIf we could reliably track politicians' money flows, their opinions, their comments and their actual actions in a system that's easily queriable, it might just be easy enough for the common people to be more aware of their rulers.
- chaostree 11y agoThere are two questions I would be asking: 1) How can we build more resilient technologies so that copyright law becomes irrelevant? (And note that we already have some candidates - like IPFS) 2) What technologies do we need so that we do not need politicians? For example, is it possible to create nation-states that are small (think hundreds of thousands of people) and allow people to create their own easily?
- raverbashing 11y agoNo 1 - If you make them more expensive then only the truly wealthy will be able to buy them. Yes, they exist 2 - Corruption is a matter mainly of personal ethics and perception of things around you. Of course it's hard to turn down heavily compensated engagements or other types of 'incentives' given by big players. Especially when everybody does it. It's really an issue of Game Theory
- AnthonyMouse 11y ago> How can we make it more expensive to buy politicians? You're thinking about it the wrong way. You make it more expensive and fewer people can afford to do it. How do we make it cheaper to buy politicians, so that we can do it too?
- azernik 11y agoOr, they get threatened with loss of their seats. Which is accomplished by educating the population. It's a lot more gratifying to live in this conspiratorial world where a romanticized resistance against our corporate overlords is the only way, but it's not a useful mental model for actually succeeding at anything.
- scotty79 11y ago> Or, they get threatened with loss of their seats. They get seats by spending money on campaigns. Public is easily manipulated by political marketing. The only thing that could put them out of there seats would be more money spent for a smear campaign against them. > It's a lot more gratifying to live in this conspiratorial world where a romanticized resistance against our corporate overlords is the only way, but it's not a useful mental model for actually succeeding at anything. As opposed to romanticized world where money (got from industry) put into political marketing has no effect on votes and you achieve political goals by educating voters (at no cost other than your sincere effort)?
- twoodfin 11y agoYou might want to look into how much money Jeb Bush's Super PAC has spent in the primary season so far, to very little effect.
- ddingus 11y agoAt the National level, it does appear lots of money won't necessarily translate into a win. However, those who do win, unless they are named Sanders, will be bound by said money. On a local level, money does matter more, and it's effects are meaningful.
- cmdkeen 11y agoOn a local level a huge number of candidates run unopposed. Even for Congress there were 31 unopposed candidates in 2014. Money isn't everything. Giving a damn matters too.
- k-mcgrady 11y ago>> "Politicians don't get educated. They get bought. Do you have as much money as copyright industry? No? Then, no, you can't have your sensible laws. You'll have theirs. The only action you can take is to ignore those unenforcible." Then you need to fix your political system before you can fix the law. As an outsider looking in it seems like sorting out how campaigns are financed would be a good first step and that seems like something Bernie Sanders wants to and probably can fix. So the opportunity is there for you to take if the issue is important enough to you.
- mwfunk 11y agoIf you take the low road every time, then the best you can hope for is a world in which everyone takes the low road all the time. I don't want to live in that world. In this case, the low road probably won't even get you where you want to go, so you're not even reaping a tangible benefit from it.
- jMyles 11y agoThe low road is abiding by a ridiculous, regressive, industrial-age law because somebody with a gun told you to. The high road is the one where your conscience gets to weigh-in, and you do right in spite of your fear.