2 ms·
> I generally agree with your argument, but there's an argument to be made that rich people benefit more from eg protection of property by the police, because t
by AnthonyMouse 11y ago
> I generally agree with your argument, but there's an argument to be made that rich people benefit more from eg protection of property by the police, because they do have more property.
That isn't a problem on the tax side, it's a problem on the services side. (And that specific example is almost irrelevant because enforcing property rights is such a tiny proportion of government expenditures.) If the rich are getting $5500 worth of government services and the poor are getting $4500, then change what services the government provides.
Although notice that it's still progressive even in that case as long as the difference is small: If the rich pay $10,000 in taxes and get $5500 in government services while the poor pay $2500 in taxes and get $4500 in government services, there is still a transfer of wealth from rich to poor.
A good way to dispense with the calculations is to make the primary "government service" a basic income. You don't get $5000 in "government services," you just get $5000.
- eru 11y agoTrue, a proper accounting would tell you that providing property safety is a small proportion of the overall expenditure. A somewhat similar argument can be made against minimum wage: even if it works perfectly well, it's people shopping at Walmart that pay for the increases compared to market wage. People shopping at Walmart are probably poorer than the national average, so why not make the overall population pay in eg negative income taxes or a basic income to help poor Walmart employees. (A slightly more sophisticated argument would yield a similar conclusion, even if Walmart's stockholders were bearing the difference between market wages and minimum wages.)