3 ms·
Social taboos against unpopular opinions may not rise to the level of criminalization, but that doesn't mean they are all perfectly acceptable. The Hollywood bl
by philwelch 11y ago
Social taboos against unpopular opinions may not rise to the level of criminalization, but that doesn't mean they are all perfectly acceptable. The Hollywood blacklist wasn't a government action nor was it a violation of free speech in the legal sense, but that didn't make it a good or even an acceptable thing. Actually, we consider it a great scandal when screenwriters are blacklisted from their livelihood for expressing sympathies with Stalin, but we don't bat an eye when a tech executive is hounded out of his job because he backed the wrong California proposition a few years ago and refuses to comment on the issue today. One of these is called "McCarthyism" and the other is called "political correctness", and it's hard for me to see a world where one is okay and the other is not, unless of course we live in a world where denying legal marriage to same sex couples is worse than Stalinism.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> The Hollywood blacklist wasn't a government action nor was it a violation of free speech in the legal sense, but that didn't make it a good or even an acceptable thing. Well, yeah, it was an combination in restraint of trade. Which is whole different category of wrong than a free speech violation.
- philwelch 11y agoSo we agree that hounding people out of their livelihoods over their expressed opinions is wrong, then.
- dragonwriter 11y agoNot sure how you inferred any comment on that subject from my simply pointing out that the Hollywood blacklist was a combination in restraint of trade. Which, incidentally, the complaints about Eich were not.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoIf you actually knew anything about the blacklists of the 1950s (hint: it went far beyond Hollywood) you would realize how absurd it is to compare that to the man who gave us javascript.