3 ms·
> people are just fine with [VAT] Er, not quite. I for one would rather see VAT disappear. It's a regressive tax, it hits the poor (and start-ups) disproportio
by toyg 11y ago
> people are just fine with [VAT]
Er, not quite. I for one would rather see VAT disappear. It's a regressive tax, it hits the poor (and start-ups) disproportionately, and it's basically just a huge "get out of jail" card for lazy lawmakers who won't dare to tax the rich. Which is why it is so "popular" around elites of every country.
- zardo 11y agoDon't they tax luxury items at a higher rate? The appeal of a VAT is that you can incent economic expansion in one are over another, ie... Better baby food over swankier yachts.
- alextgordon 11y agoRich people don't spend all their money on consumption like poor people have to do. Their money goes into equities, houses, investments that appreciate over time.
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoIf I didn't know better I would think there was a conspiracy by the rich to convince people that consumption taxes are regressive because they know they're the only way the rich can be made to pay their taxes. Think about someone who has a billion dollars. Not income, already in the bank. Without a consumption tax, they can spend all of it without paying any taxes. Now think about someone who has student loans or a mortgage (i.e. someone not rich enough to pay for it outright). With an income tax they have to pay income tax on the money they're using to pay back the loan principal. Switch to a consumption tax and they don't. So where does this idea that consumption taxes are regressive come from? The theory is supposed to be that the rich spend less of their income than the poor. First small problem, that's only true for the super rich. Someone making $120K/year is pretty well spending it all on a big house and a new car and sending their kids to college. It's the people who have a billion dollars and make ten million a year in interest who aren't spending anywhere near that much. But those same people also don't have anywhere near that much in "taxable" income because they have fancy accountants and the investments they own don't have definite values until sold, which they never are. So they can make a million dollars in interest without paying any tax, and then they can use a different million dollars in principal to spend on anything they like, also without paying any tax. But if we had a consumption tax on cars and yachts and airfare, they would be paying that. So which one is the regressive one?
- toyg 11y ago> Without a consumption tax, they can spend all of it without paying any taxes. But even with VAT they almost don't, that's the thing. Because they can afford not-even-that-fancy accountants (or just one), they can simply reclaim the tax as business expense or shuffle most of it downstream to whoever is buying their services (there are bazillions of rules, of course, but they are not that hard to bend). People without accountants and company ownership cannot do that. Say a "normal" guy buys car X, paying £1000 -- 200 of those go in tax. A "vat-savvy" guy buys the same car through his company, pays £1k, then claims VAT as a business expense. In practice, he's just bought the same car for £800. This is widespread, and obviously frowned upon by tax authorities, but it's like emptying the sea with a spoon. (Note: cars are actually more regulated than other items, exactly because of this sort of trick happening since the beginning of time on a well-known expensive item, but there are plenty of equivalent items that go undetected). > The theory is supposed to be that the rich spend less of their income than the poor. It's not just that, it's that in absolute terms the exact same thing is taxed in exactly the same way for rich and poor alike. That is regressive, like all flat taxes. It wouldn't be if and only if rich people only ever bought more expensive luxury items, which is not true in practice: they buy a lot of stuff in the same malls working-class people use, but they pay the exact same flat tax on each sweater. > So which one is the regressive one? It's a false dichotomy -- you can (and should) use multiple types of taxation at the same time. It's pretty clear that personal income taxes are not sufficient, but the answer is not removing those to introduce flat consumption taxes which are even worse in real terms; the answer is to increase taxation on capital profits, rent and property, which is where the real wealth lies. Tax theory is old and fairly well-understood from a systemic perspective, but obviously nobody wants to piss off their political donors, whereas little people are easily gamed.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y agoIn which country can you claim back VAT on cars? In Austria there is a tiny list of cars on which you can do that. Besides you can't just put stuff as business expensive without justifying it.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago