4 ms·
> If it makes sense to reduce the tax revenue you can generally lower taxes for all products. This isn't about reducing tax revenue; this is about not increasi
by JoshTriplett 11y ago
> If it makes sense to reduce the tax revenue you can generally lower taxes for all products.
This isn't about reducing tax revenue; this is about not increasing it, and specifically about not creating a new tax.
If tax revenue has gone down in some other area, the presumption should not automatically be to raise taxes elsewhere to compensate.
> I'm not sure how it works in the US, but in the EU services (including internet access) are generally taxed with a VAT, just like every other product
Taxes in the US aren't nearly that uniform. Goods and services are not taxed universally at the federal level; many such goods and services have one-off special-case taxes. For instance, phone service has several taxes. Internet service, however, does not. This bill is a statement against adding new special-case taxes for the Internet, and against adding new taxes for goods and services purchased through the Internet specifically because of their method of purchase.
Imposing any kind of universal sales tax would be an entirely separate question.
> I say exactly the opposite: you can use taxing to make people buy more of something (some new tech you want to push) or less (e.g. cigarettes).
The US has various such subsidies and excise taxes (the latter of which I already mentioned). But this isn't an instance of that; this is simply choosing not to create a new tax on the Internet.