4 ms·
I don't know what confusion of ideas created your current state of mind, but a reduction in tax is not a subsidy. The maximum benefit to the economy is achieve
by logfromblammo 11y ago
I don't know what confusion of ideas created your current state of mind, but a reduction in tax is not a subsidy.
The maximum benefit to the economy is achieved when economic distortion due to tax or subsidy is zero.
Consider the traditional supply vs demand plot:
$| \D S/ In an undistorted market,
| \ / the equilibrium point where
| \ / D and S intersect determine
A|----X the price (A) and quantity (B)
| /|\ that will be sold.
| / | \
| / | \
+---------
B #
The consumer benefit to trade is the area below D and above A. The producer benefit to trade is the area below A and above S.
$| \D S/ In a taxed market, the tax
C|--\ / creates a difference between
| |\ / what the consumer pays (C) and
A| | X what the producer gets (E).
| |/ \ As a result, the quantity sold
E|--/ \ drops to a lower value (F).
| /| \
+---------
F B #
The tax revenue is the area above E, below C, and left of F. It is possible this can be returned to the economy intact, if the government spends it wisely. The triangle of the former benefit of trade to the right of F and left of B is deadweight loss, and is lost forever. The new consumer benefit is above C and below D, while the new producer benefit is below E and above S.
$| \D S/ In a subsidized market, the subsidy
G|--\---/ creates a difference between
| \ /| what the consumer pays (H) and
A| X | what the producer gets (G).
| / \| As a result, the quantity sold
H|--/---\ increases to a higher value (I).
| / |\
+---------
B I #
The cost of the subsidy is the area below G, above H, and left of I. This produces an additional consumer benefit below A and D, and above H, and additional producer benefit above A and S, and below G. Note that this produces another triangular area of deadweight loss that the government spends to produce zero additional economic benefit.
In conclusion, a reduction in tax cannot in any way be reasonably considered equivalent to a subsidy.
- maerF0x0 11y agoCorrect, its not a subsidy under your definition. But it is a relative advantage compared to other products (in layman's terms this is very close to the meaning of subsidy) . Considering i have a pool of $50 to spend, I can buy more internet access now (or will begin to buy internet access) to the extent that the marginal dollars give the greatest utility over other products (which are taxed). Ex: imagine a internet plan is taxed such that it is $50 under the old taxed regime and $45 under the new taxed regime. Under the old regime, internet access purchases had to compete against other choices that cost $50. Under the new regime internet access will compete against $45 choices. Anyone currently not spending $50 on internet because other $50 dollar choices are better may shift away under the new regime because the $45 internet is a better choice than the still normally priced $50 choice. As well, to the extent that the government spends tax money on anything ISP related, that expenditure is now a greater net subsidy than prior cases where some amount of tax offsets the subsidy (eg, $50 subsidy - $5 tax ==> $45 net subsidy in the old regime becomes $50 subsidy - $0tax ==> $50 net subsidy in the new regime)
- barrkel 11y agoSelective reduction in tax is indistinguishable from a subsidy.
- logfromblammo 11y agoIt is indistinguishable to any individual consumer or producer, and usually to the government, but in aggregate, it is distinguishable by comparing the amounts of the deadweight losses before and after the change. The consumers only see where the market is trading relative to their position on the demand curve. The producers only see where the market is trading relative to their position on the supply curve. Any party persuasive enough to know the total price and quantity traded in the market might be able to estimate deadweight losses by analyzing the market data before and after changes in the magnitude of manipulation, and extrapolating from the slopes of the two curves. If a reduction in a tax is paid for by an increase in another tax, the effect is determined by the shapes of the supply and demand curves in those different markets, and is not easily calculated, as any given consumer or producer only knows a tiny fragment of the information needed. That's the problem with the science of economics as a guide for political economic policies. No one gets mad about the numbers they can never calculate. Even though every tax and every subsidy inevitably results in the metaphorical equivalent of digging a huge hole, throwing tons of other people's money in, and lighting it on fire, no one really knows whether that bonfire is a net benefit or detriment to them, personally. Some people would be quite happy to burn $100k of other people's money if they got an extra $10k for themselves as a result. Some people would be happy to destroy $100k forever, just to reduce the total number of tobacco cigarettes sold by 0.5%. As a thought experiment, imagine an economy with only two goods: Foo and Bar. Now copy it. In your copy, you tax Foo by 10% of its final sale price, and every last penny collected from that tax goes to subsidize Bar. Run both simulated economies in your head for a few years, and try to determine the effects.