4 ms·
Self-reported as having once had a home. SO, grain of salt.
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
Self-reported as having once had a home. SO, grain of salt.
- nwah1 11y agoWhy would they lie?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kafkaesq 11y agoMany people believe the homeless are, by and large possessed of intrinsically low intelligence and/or ethical character, and generally have only themselves to blame for their situation. So (this reasoning goes) when approached by a pollster, why wouldn't they lie?
- JBReefer 11y agoOr, less snarkily, some people believe that homeless people are rational actors like the rest of us, and therefore gravitate towards the regions with the highest cash benefits/most generous housing programs/etc. Therefore, it would behoove the homeless to protect those benefits by lying about their point of origination to garner more sympathy from those who pay for their benefits.
- anigbrowl 11y agoAssuming that people are lying on surveys is quite common, but unless there's systematic organized bias sampling theory suggests an approximately equal number of people will lie in the opposite direction and that both 'signals' will fall into the noise floor.
- JBReefer 11y agoHowever, if there's an incentive to lie, the lies will trend towards the incented direction
- astrodust 11y agoThis is pretty low even by Hacker News standards. There are some highly intelligent people who are homeless, they have no ethical problems. They may have dependency issues, they might have a mental illness. In the US it's even possible they got wiped out by medical bills and can't afford anything, their credit is destroyed and they're not physically able to work, yet that's just the visible homeless, not all of the actually homeless people. I've been technically homeless for six months. Even though I had money, I had a job, and I spent every day looking for listings, finding a place was crazy hard, every listing would be snapped up within hours of being posted. I ended up couch surfing and living out of my office. It didn't matter that I had a job, that I even owned the company, I was still homeless. It sucked. The place I was renting was sold, I had to move, and the timing was awful. Long-term homeless people have a host of issues that keep them in that trap, but that's a small portion of homeless people in general.
- kafkaesq 11y agoThis is pretty low even by Hacker News standards. Woah, big misunderstanding here: I was pointing out that other people believed that -- not that that's what I believe.
- astrodust 11y ago"Home" here means "place to live" not "house".
- kafkaesq 11y agograin of salt Or a heap of FUD thrown at a very serious and pervasive problem.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoFolks who self-report are notorious for trying to please the questioner. No agenda here. Just curious: do these folks have any id? Could we perhaps google them vs housing records, property deeds, or other public information and determine if they used to own or rent in SF? All that effort to do this enormous survey, and they couldn't be troubled to check the data they were getting. Maybe this particular statistic wasn't central to their goal. But anyway, take 71% with a grain of salt.
- kafkaesq 11y agoJust curious: do these folks have any id? Some do, many don't. Either way doesn't say much about where they were living 2 or 20 years ago. Could we perhaps google them vs housing records, property deeds, or other public information and determine if they used to own or rent in SF? You "could" but it would be a pretty bad idea -- it's safe to assume most of these people weren't ever property owners, and (if they did rent) lived in regular privately-rented dwellings, i.e. with no public record.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoThat assumption is the cart before the horse. The statistic implies these folks used to come from every walk of life. Including homeowners. I don't know why we'd every jump to the conclusion they were low class renters. Anyway, this is what a good survey would answer. But we get self-reporting and dubious statistics.
- kafkaesq 11y agoThe statistic implies these folks used to come from every walk of life. Not quite. Just that they weren't always in their current position. I don't know why we'd every jump to the conclusion they were low class renters. Most likely just "renters."
- gtk40 11y agoIt seems like the three categories that make up the 100% are where they had a home before: 71% SF, 19% elsewhere in CA, 10% out of state. Are you saying that they are lying about having had a place of residence ever before? What would that mean?
- anigbrowl 11y agoAs opposed to career homeless people who have been doing it since they were born. Pretty much everyone has had a home of some sort at some stage (defining home as a more-or-less stable living situation, not property ownership).