5 ms·
Ask HN: Science vs Religion: how is it compatible?
How can science and religion be compatible (without some heavy twist of the mind)?
I'm aware that talking about religion is taboo and I hope this will not degenerate into a flame war. The reason I'm asking here is because I know HN has a very rational and intelligent audience. Yet, many of you are religious and I'd genuinely like to hear your perspective.
EDIT: I personally believe they are incompatible because they reach to different conclusions: age of the universe, Darwinian evolution, dinosaurs, etc.
- rudin 17y agoWell I am going to separate religion into its main components and decide on each one. The community aspect. Going to a church. Helping your local community etc. All this stuff is totally compatible with Science of course but it is another question if it could succeed without the other religious aspects. Morality. Science, through Darwin's theories, does explain why we are moral but this is separate to teaching people how to be moral so this area is compatible as well. Creation stories, miracles. Science destroys these. Philosophy is probably the wrong approach to deal with the question of existence, it will leads towards untestable hypotheses and so towards religion. Let Physics go at it for a few hundred more years.
- dirtbox 17y agoI'm more interested in the reasoning behind believing that the two should be incompatible.
- olalonde 17y agoIt seemed obvious to me but I guess I'm biased. Perhaps I should have explained my arguments.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- tokenadult 17y agoThe reason I'm asking here is because I know HN has a very rational and intelligent audience. To ask a serious question, also not intended to start a flame war, how do you know that?
- tokenadult 17y agoThe reason I'm asking here is because I know HN has a very rational and intelligent audience. To ask a serious question, also not intended to start a flame war, how do you know that?
- olalonde 17y agoFrom discussions that usually happen on HN. Don't you share the same perception?
- dirtbox 17y agoMy perception is that religion is never mentioned, because it has no bearing on any subjects discussed.
- olalonde 17y agoAgreed, although you're not answering the question.
- dirtbox 17y agoOkay, I'll bite. I'm atheist, but open minded to all things. No heavy twist of mind required here. The Christianity you seem to prescribe to (due to mentioning Darwinism, age of the universe and so on) seems, to me at least, a slightly more fundamental branch of thinking that's far more common in North America http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/bigphotos/21329204.html http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/bigphotos/21329204.h... Incidentally that's certainly not meant as any kind of slight against anyone as I respect and accept everyone's beliefs equally, it's just that the line of thinking where two such notions should be branded as incompatible is quite alien to me.
- olalonde 17y agoNever mind, I thought it was tokenadult who had written your reply above.
- tokenadult 17y ago
- noonespecial 17y agoTheist here: Science and religion both address certain and different parts of our existence. Science is the tool we use to look at our universe and ask what, religion is the tool we use to look at our universe and ask why. For example, science is perfect for looking at our earth and asking "what is it, what caused it, what's in it?" etc. Religion is perfect for asking "why is there a universe at all?" (or more succinctly, "why is there something and not nothing?") The problems start when you use science, or religion to ask or answer the wrong questions. Example: You can't use science to look for God because science only works on everything in the universe. If there is a God worth the title, he/she/it is not going to be in there. If you do, you're just going to find a whole lot of universe, like a character in "the sims" trying to use game elements to prove there's a player. Example: You can't really use religion to ask where the earth (and life) came form (what caused it) because its just one link in a (perhaps limitless) cause-effect chain that is the universe, fully defined within its own context. If you do, you end up with a cartoon-like image of a tiny god, contained within the universe using his god-powers to create static creatures to try to outsmart the big bad universe. It might make you feel warm and fuzzy, but it doesn't do much for the concept of God. The big problems come when people militantly use the wrong tool to answer a question. Then you get people staring up at stars that emitted their light 100 million years ago and insisting that it all started 6500 years ago, and insisting that they be allowed to teach that to your kids on your dime. And there begins the heavy twisting of mind. If you carefully think about the goals you are trying to achieve with each, I don't feel that science and religion are fundamentally incompatible. Edit: Had to search a bit for this Einstein quote but here is: "There is no conflict between science and religion. Science asks what the world is, and religion asks what humankind and society should become" - Albert Einstein
- olalonde 17y agoAssuming you are a Christian, do you believe the Bible should be taken literally or do you think it is composed of metaphors? Where do you draw the line between fact and fiction?
- noonespecial 17y agoThis always begins a fascinating discussion involving cosmologies, life histories, logic and beliefs, but as we bridge the gap from "religion" to "specific religion" we find ourselves in the kind of discussion that should be had with good friends over beers in cherished local places. I find that once you enter this territory, venues like HN don't support this type of discussion well, so I'm going to make the choice to lay it down here, but you sound like someone I'd like to have a beer or two with.
- lsc 17y agoscience and religion are compatible if, and only if, you use religion only in areas where science does not provide useful answers. (of course, this is something of a moving target.)
- known 17y ago"Religion was born when the first con man met the first fool." --Mark Twain
- known 17y agoReligion is like investing in Lottery. Science is like investing in Stock Market
- losethos 17y agoGod says... Newsletters contained darksomely roll pronounced vestige dominion anniversary superior haled needy another Head readers confession flocks Themselves admired heads whole recognises upbraid ludicrous earthly clothed Courage wherein Replacement formed Orestes controversy nourishments intermission fortunate halved inebriate final stiffly Court vulgar
- scorpioxy 17y agoIn my opinion, religion is not compatible with Science. Faith is. At least incompatible when discussing the level of details that religion usually talks about. I'm not a fan of that.
- losethos 17y agoReligion must be empirically based, not philosophically. The problem is modern religion no longer does miracles. You must do mysticism. Take a nansosecond stop watch, sample it when you press a button, use the number as a mystical random value. Or, just crack-open a book randomly. How can you think the brilliant Greeks were stupid believing in an oracle? You really think they deluded themselves? God says... unskilfulness knitting reform vigorous Especially satisfying consolation high Either tends discontent flies darkness
- roundsquare 17y agoOne way they are compatible is by picking and choosing what to believe in. This seems to be the most common approach I've seen, though its often done by not looking too closely at the topic. However, I imagine you want something more satisfying than that. What you're saying makes sense If A and B reach contradictory conclusions, than one of them must be false. However, I think a lot of problems come from thinking that we understand reality. We're just starting to scratch the surface so we may discover things that allow us to accept both science and religion. The analogy I like is of the guy who tried to see how much it rained by throwing spaghetti on the wall. Thats the wrong tool to use. Maybe logic/our brains are not powerful enough to answer these questions. (Apologies, this is not the best explanation of what I'm trying to say).
- rms 17y agohttp://lesswrong.com/lw/i8/religions_claim_to_be_nondisprovable/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/i8/religions_claim_to_be_nondisprova... My belief is that science and religion are reconcilable, but by the time you become a rational theist, what's the point of still being a theist? You'll have already rationalized away most of your core beliefs, like a God that is really answering your prayers. By the way, you can discuss this at Less Wrong with an obnoxiously rational crowd, but you'll probably get mercilessly downmodded because the question is answered already in the existing writing. Doing some more reading on Less Wrong should help make you more confident in your existing answer to the question.
- stonemetal 17y agoI am Buddhist my religion specifies no conclusions regarding the age of the universe, evolution etc. If you meant Christians well my wife is Catholic and while they are a little slow on the up take (aka Galileo). They currently support Darwin etc. The sub set of people who have issues with the age of the universe, evolution etc. are merely uneducated in both matters of science and religion.