3 ms·
> This punishes newcomers and rewards staying in the same property, just like California Prop 13. Have a kid and need a new place with more space? Prepare to pa
by munificent 11y ago
> This punishes newcomers and rewards staying in the same property, just like California Prop 13. Have a kid and need a new place with more space? Prepare to pay punishing property taxes for that luxury. You grew up in the area and it's time to move out? Enjoy your tax! Moving from the countryside for better employment opportunities? Tax please!
Can you explain why this would be a moving tax?
Obvious, property taxes only apply to the fraction of the year that you own a place. Are you worried about the overlapping period where you have the house on the market but haven't sold it yet?
I suppose that would be an issue, but I assume for most people, that's a relatively small fraction of time. It's not like there aren't already lots of other expenses associated with moving.
- Zach_the_Lizard 11y ago>Can you explain why this would be a moving tax? >Obvious, property taxes only apply to the fraction of the year that you own a place. Are you worried about the overlapping period where you have the house on the market but haven't sold it yet? The proposal was to create a property tax that phases out once the owner has lived there for X period of time. Naturally, every time you sell and move you then reset this clock, so you'd pay the property tax only if you keep moving. The most monetarily rational strategy is to buy and hold forever if at all possible. In short, the only way to trigger this tax is to move.
- dnr 11y agoI think the OP meant ten months per year, or in general, a fixed fraction of the period that the property tax is assessed over.