4 ms·
> a foundational principle of our judicial system You are sorely misguided if you believe a foundational principle of our judicial system is deliberate and sys
by Alupis 11y ago
> a foundational principle of our judicial system
You are sorely misguided if you believe a foundational principle of our judicial system is deliberate and systematic invasion of innocent citizens' private communications.
> no data center any country can build will ever so much as recover a single emoji from a single IM
This is fine and how it should be. Historically there has been no way to intercept communications on this level ever before - so why claim it's suddenly necessary now? Especially since all of it has amounted to exactly nothing thus far...
This analogy has been beaten to death - but the parallels are almost exact when compared to Stasi Secret Police steaming open citizens hand-written letters for inspection... As others have already mentioned, one of the driving forces behind our nation was desire for private communications that the government didn't have entitled and unrestricted access to.
- tptacek 11y agoI'm not sure who you're arguing with, but I don't think it's me.
- Alupis 11y ago> I'm not sure who you're arguing with, but I don't think it's me. Those quotes are from you... And coupled with the general tone in majority of your posts in this thread... it's painfully clear you fundamentally believe the government not being able to intercept and access all private electronic communications the world-over is a major problem... Taking this to it's logical conclusion, you support weakening, backdooring, or somehow subverting generalized end-user encryption in order to "aide" law enforcement (to whatever end). This is an absurd stance for anyone who works in technology to take. The government is not just kicking around the idea of banning/backdooring full-device encryption, but even run-of-the-mill encryption such as SSL/TLS because it can be used to mask communications just the same. In this world, you wont even be safe purchasing goods online, let alone conducting banking, etc. It literally is incompatible with the technology we need to drive today's world. So please get off the "government needs this to stop bad guys" high horse and come back down to reality. There is not a world where anyone is safe without strong encryption.
- pvg 11y agoSo first you're going going to put words into his mouth claiming he supports things he explicitly disavows and then you're going to be condescending and rude about it. That's, well, condescending and rude, beside being an outright misrepresentation of someone else's views, whatever you may think of them.
- Alupis 11y agoSorry, nobody gets a free pass or special treatment here, no matter how many points they may have. Making contradictory statements, or provocatory statements without giving "the other side" argument is going to be perceived as support for that one particular viewpoint. That is what happened here, in many occurrences (you are encouraged to go read the thread in full). Those statements are what my posts, and those by others, sought to argue against. So don't come around, way after things have settled, and attempt to reprimand someone for doing precisely what was intended while simultaneously exhibiting the exact behavior you perceived as inflammatory.
- pvg 11y agoI think what you're asking for is the special treatment of 'right to misrepresent someone's views because you don't agree with them' and then being a jerk about it. That's what I read in the thread.
- dang 11y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11088674 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11088674 and marked it off-topic.