3 ms·
How is this not extremely illegal? People have gone to prison for far less. How is it possible that a company like Lenovo would get involved with this? I recen
by mcv 11y ago
How is this not extremely illegal? People have gone to prison for far less. How is it possible that a company like Lenovo would get involved with this?
I recently found myself wondering if I should consider CNET a reliable source of software. I guess this story answers that.
- StavrosK 11y agoProtip: If a site wants you to download an installer, or has its own installer for the software it provides, don't use it.
- derpadelt 11y ago> Protip That's the problem: We should not need to be "pro" to get software - even in an open world without walled gardens.
- Houshalter 11y agoAlmost all software comes with an installer. Might as well just not download software over the internet, which makes it impossible to do anything.
- StavrosK 11y agoSorry, I meant a site installer, like those random "download.com installer" software. Not the installer of the program itself. Generally, if the installer is branded with the branding of the third-party you downloaded a program from, stay away.
- npstr 11y agoWhy are you even using CNET instead of the original website of any software to get the installer?
- mcv 11y agoRecently I couldn't find an installer on the official site of something I needed. Googling for one lead me to CNET.
- mrec 11y agoWhich raises the next obvious question - why isn't Google blacklisting these sites yet?
- anexprogrammer 11y agoWell in Google's case it's easy, wouldn't want to upset that ad income. Firefox though absolutely should be blocking/warning of malware for sites like this. Firefox is more spin than substance these days, sadly.
- mcv 11y agoBut these are companies overwriting Google's ads with their own. Sounds like Google is directly hurt by them. Maybe blacklisting would get them charged with anticompetitive behaviour? (That would be really funny in a horrifying way if that happened.)
- randunel 11y agoWhy do you support private companies policing the internet? I'd rather be given the chance to decide what's good or bad for me by myself, instead of having someone else doing this proactively. A warning would be welcomed, but nothing more.
- delecti 11y agoWebsites are still accessible if Google delists them.
- whorleater 11y agoThat's akin to saying if I tore up the road leading to your house, your house is still accessible. You're not wrong, but you can't deny the power that Google has when it comes to access to websites. Furthermore, if Google started delisting some websites, you probably wouldn't even notice, which makes this all the scarier. There's a solution to be found that doesn't involve Google acting as some kind of pseudo-internet police.
- taloft 11y agoSeems like intercepting secure communications with a bank would be a criminal activity and those responsible would be treated as such.
- pjc50 11y agoIndividuals go to prison for hacking, especially if it's anything to do with copyright. Businesses definitely are given the benefit of the doubt. The public lack a well-funded consumer advocacy organisation that can bribe, cajole or threaten police into investigating this kind of crime.
- mcv 11y agoBut why are businesses given the benefit of the doubt? Surely if crimes like these are core to their business, that business is a criminal organization, and its members should be locked up? Could any criminal organization decide to incorporate and file taxes and get just a slap on the wrist and a fine for their drug trade, mugging, etc? Reminds me of HSBC's minor fine for laundering billions of drug dollars. Why do corporations get that kind of immunity?
- pjc50 11y agoCapitalism? More generally, people have prejudices about what crime "looks like", which isn't an office, and there is a huge pro-business bias generally in the West based on the idea of "creating jobs".
- jerf 11y agoI don't think that's a good answer; in general governments get even more latitude to screw up than businesses do. I think it's just that groups with diffused responsibility get more latitude, because for a given act, who are you going to put in jail exactly? That turns out to be a hard question, especially when you consider not just the local consequences but the global ones. For instance, take a hard line "I'm putting the CEO/Secretary of X/Whatever the highest plausible person is in jail" stance and you just created an extraordinary incentive for pervasive, total micromanagement, and probably in the end worse results for society than even what we have now. It's a hard problem.
- pjc50 11y agoInteresting that you say "screw up", which implies error rather than malice. Maybe that's an important part of it that we look at intent of individuals and then label them "bad", whereas the intent of a business decision is harder to label?
- turbohz 11y agoYou are probably agreeing to it by accepting an EULA?