7 ms·
If only Microsoft had run with the idea of package management and trusted repos that has existed in open source for decades without restrictions that inspire pe
by michaelmrose 11y ago
If only Microsoft had run with the idea of package management and trusted repos that has existed in open source for decades without restrictions that inspire people NOT to use it. Example to release a debian repo to share your software with your users you have the option to handle hosting/payment if any yourself and keep 100% of the revenue not 70%.
Their position in the market is such that had they started pushing this around the time apt-get started to be a thing they would have had near 100% adoption and users would be used to installing everything that way and would be naturally suspicious of manual installation.
Bad actors could end up on a blacklist that users would opt to enable. You would even have multiple black list sources from people like antivirus vendors etc.
- cm2187 11y agoJava is a bad actor. But I don't get to choose to use it or not. If it was up to me I would never use java and its attempts to install malware on my machine, its habbit of bugging me every day with update pop ups, and creating security holes in my browser, etc. But unfortunately if I want to be able to work from home occasionally I need to have software chosen by my employer running on my machine. Putting it on some blacklist wouldn't help.
- CJefferson 11y agoDo you really want to live in that world? The world where I have to get past Google's, Apple's (iOS and Mac app store), Debian's and Steam's arbitrary rules about what is and isn't an acceptable app? Where a company/project's current head gets to decide what it is, and isn't, acceptable to install? One of the reasons Windows flourished was the openness of the platform.
- libeclipse 11y agoLinux is a much more open platform than windows. It's only downside is that most people think it's difficult to use. I cannot think of any reasons why you'd think windows is open, especially when comparing it to Linux. You were talking about installing, yet fail to realise that pkg managers aren't the only way. I mean most Linux users regularly compile binaries directly from the source. How is that not open? Perhaps you'd like to elaborate.
- cmdkeen 11y agoBecause part of being open is being accessible. "It was on display at the bottom of a locked filing cabinet stuck in a disused lavatory with a sign on the door saying beware of the leopard." Linux is difficult to use for the kind of person who is downloading software from Download.com - "compiling binaries directly from the source" might as well be Klingon to them. Frankly as a geek I'm much happier with my Mac and Windows machine than I am with Linux. Even now things like the Linux Standard Base not being utterly standard demonstrate that Linux is still aiming for a different market. There is a gulf between "my Mom is running Debian, she thinks it is Windows, hehehe" and "able to manage a Linux box even remotely competently".
- bramblerose 11y agoPlus: compiling from source does not mean the code is ad/spyware free.
- jacquesm 11y agoOk, assuming that it does not, how many instances in the wild have there been of ad/spyware distributed as source to be compiled on the target machine?
- madeofpalk 11y agoI would imagine that in a world where my mum is compiling from the 'source', the 'source' that she's compiling would be infected in the same way as Download.com is.
- petetnt 11y ago"Mom I have told you thousands of times! Configure, make and make install, not configure and make install!"
- lmm 11y agoUbuntu shipped a spyware package with a few releases. I assume they had a source release with the same package configuration, in which case they were doing exactly that.
- deciplex 11y agouhhhhh.... Nothing about apt is walled off at all.
- rmc 11y agoDebian, that well known walled garden.
- Cthulhu_ 11y agoWhich one of the apps on download.com (that bundle crapware) would not be considered acceptable in a store? What crazy apps wouldn't conform to those rules? And how many people would actually be interested in those apps? I've jailbroken an iOS device once just to check out what amazing things apple doesn't want in the store. I wasn't impressed; cydia looked like crap, iOS <7 looks bolted in an ipad app, tacky icons everywhere, and the top X downloads were all tacky looking mods for things like the lock screen. That was back when though, I've looked up some lists of stuff and I'll admit some of the available things can be convenient if you're into that sort of thing.
- bitJericho 11y agoI have a computer illiterate family member on Ubuntu. He's easily able to install software outside the repo as long as the process is spelled out. See google earth's install process on Ubuntu.
- runholm 11y agoLinux solve that by allowing users to add repositories. I don't see why that would not work for Microsoft as well.
- anon1385 11y agoThat just means malware sites like download.com will tell users to add the download.com repository. Without curation package managers/app stores don't offer any additional security, but curation inevitably involves trusting somebody to make those decisions. Do you trust Microsoft to do that for most users?
- chris_wot 11y agoI do. I run Windows update on any machine that someone asks me to look at.
- fpoling 11y agoConsider Chromebooks - one can unlock ChromeOS or replace it with Linux, but Google made it rather scary-sounding process for an average user, so malware site has very little chances to convenience the user to do it.
- anon1385 11y agoChromeOS isn't an open platform and Chromebooks are dangerously locked down. Microsoft could solve these issues on windows by forbidding software that they don't approve. It would undoubtedly improve the security of the platform. But it turns Windows into a walled garden instead of an open platform (consider - would Microsoft have allowed Firefox onto the platform? unlikely)
- chris_wot 11y agoDebian, Ubuntu, RedHat, SuSE and a multitude of Linux distributions are doing just fine. In fact, you can package up your own .rpm or .deb and still install the software. But the likelihood of needing to do so is very, very small. And not only that, but it's extremely easy to see what those packages are made of - you just unzip and untar them and look at the metadata files and scripts. So yeah, not only do I want to live in that world, I already do. In fact, so do other Windows users - if they use OneGet or chocolatey. And many, many corporate users also live in that world as software is deployed via SSIS or just bog standard Active Directory.
- laumars 11y ago> Do you really want to live in that world? The world where I have to get past Google's, Apple's (iOS and Mac app store), Debian's and Steam's arbitrary rules about what is and isn't an acceptable app? Actually yes. With the caveat that I can still install applications outside of the repositories and/or install third party repos. With Android and Debian I can. And Steam isn't quite the same since it's an application rather than OS so you can bypass Steam entirely (even on SteamOS). That way you have some reassurances (albeit no guarantees) about the software you install, plus a method to manually bypass those protections if you so desire. > One of the reasons Windows flourished was the openness of the platform. No, that's not the reason. Or at least not the openness of the _software_ platform. The reason Windows flourished was the number of IBM-compatible clones out there and the monopoly Microsoft had -and successfully campaigned to retain for many years- on said hardware. Under those conditions Windows only needed to be "good enough" to compete rather than a market leader in openness, stability, security, nor any other measure that us geeks normally consider.
- a3_nm 11y agoI don't know about the others, but Debian is certainly not trying to decide for you what is and isn't acceptable to install. Debian does not allow any kind of software in its own repositories, but it does nothing to prevent you from adding whatever repository you like, installing whatever .deb you like, and trusting whatever signing key you want to trust.
- return0 11y agoWhat if i need a different version of mono? Or a different version of cmake, or some other third party package?
- ascagnel_ 11y agoMS set one up with Windows 8, but they botched it. Their rules initially prevented open-source apps from showing up, but haven't properly enforced their own rules such that there are now plenty of clones/name-grabs on open-source projects.