5 ms·
> quantum theory does not make the same predictions as classical theory when it comes to classical experiments (mechanics, basic EM phenomena) Yes, it does. Do
by pdonis 11y ago
> quantum theory does not make the same predictions as classical theory when it comes to classical experiments (mechanics, basic EM phenomena)
Yes, it does. Do you know how the classical limit of quantum theory works? That limit is what allows us to use classical physics in the domain where it works. If that limit didn't work, we would have a serious problem with consistency.
> It only gives probabilities of results of specified experiments of certain kinds; it does not reproduce the old predictions (like definite trajectories, Moon phases or solar eclipses)
Are you aware that all of those "old predictions" can indeed be derived from quantum theory, using the classical limit I described above? The reason that works is that, in the classical limit, quantum theory predicts a probability of 1 for one result--the classical result.
> It is natural to expect of any new theory to bring new results, but demanding that it reproduces all the old ones along is too much.
You appear to have a mistaken understanding of how new theories get accepted. New theories that don't reproduce all of the predictions of the theory they replace, in the domains where the old theory is verified by experiment, are not accepted. If general relativity had not reproduced all of the predictions of Newtonian gravity in the weak field, slow motion limit, it would not have been accepted. And if quantum theory had not reproduced all of the predictions of classical physics in the classical limit, it would not have been accepted.
- effie 11y agoAs I wrote above, I agree with you on the requirements for replacement theory. My point is that a new theory of a phenomenon does not need to replace and reproduce all the results of the old theory to be considered worthwile, competing, acceptable.
- pdonis 11y agoCan you give an example of a new theory that was considered worthwhile even though it didn't replace and reproduce all the results of the old theory? I'm not aware of any. (The Copernicus example given upthread is not a valid example, as I said in response to that post.)
- effie 11y agoSchroedinger's theory of hydrogen atom and his wave mechanics (1926). It explained positions of emission lines of excited hydrogen, but it didn't explain how the atoms lose excitation energy as there is no c and no spontaneous emission in that theory. Larmor's older theory (1897) explained how the energy is lost - by EM radiation - and gave formula connecting acceleration and losses that is used to this day. Joseph Larmor, LXIII, On the theory of the Magnetic Influence on Spectra ; and on the Radiation from moving Ions, Philosophical Magazine Series 5 Vol. 44, Iss. 271, 1897 Erwin Schrodinger, Quantisierung als Eigenwertproblem. Annalen der Phys. 384 (4) (1926)
- pdonis 11y ago> Schroedinger's theory of hydrogen atom and his wave mechanics (1926). This was not a "new theory" that was competing with any "old theories". It was a tentative model in a regime where no previous theory existed, and it was never claimed to cover anything outside that limited regime. It wasn't competing with any other theories, because there were no other theories to compete with. The question of whether or not Schrodinger's model reproduced the predictions of the "old" theory never arose, because there was no "old" theory. (Technically, there was a sort of "old" theory of the hydrogen atom--Bohr's model--but Schrodinger's model did reproduce all of its correct predictions, plus it added more correct predictions of things that the Bohr model got wrong.) The position with regard to gravitational waves is very different; we already have a comprehensive, fundamental theory--General Relativity--that explains them. Any alternative theory that only explained GWs, and didn't also explain all the other experimental results that GR explains, would be a nonstarter. > Larmor's older theory (1897) This wasn't a separate "theory" at all; it was just a derivation of a particular formula using an already known theory, Maxwell's Equations.
- effie 11y agoSchroedinger theory certainly was a new theory of the atom and later of molecules at that time, successfully competing and largely replacing classical EM models of atoms and molecules such as Larmor's theory of molecules, although it didn't cover the EM radiation aspect and EM theory needs to be used in parallel with Schroedinger's to get, say, intensities of emission lines. I think this is a good example of what I was saying in the first post. It is the new benefit that the theory brings, not reproduction of every single result of the previous theories, that makes the new theory interesting and helps its adoption. Cases where the new theory completely replaces the old theory and reproduces all of its positive results happen too, but are not the only way how new knowledge is adopted.