2 ms·
Didn't the IPCC imply that their claims were from the peer reviewed literature? However, my comment was indeed agreeing with you that peer review "is not falli
by hga 17y ago
Didn't the IPCC imply that their claims were from the peer reviewed literature?
However, my comment was indeed agreeing with you that peer review "is not falling apart", and implicitly I was saying that had little to do with this part of the IPCC's shenanigans. My comment was more general, in that the IPCC and others used "peer-review" as a bludgeon against their opponents, all while they were gaming the peer-review system to exclude them.
As Phil Jones wrote to Mann: "I can't see either of these papers being in the next IPCC report. Kevin and I will keep them out somehow--even if we have to redefine what the peer-review literature is!"