4 ms·
Phillips Exeter Academy Mathematics Course Materials
- hga 17y agoWell, I guess it's no surprise that the rot has set in even at Exeter. In many ways, my below average public school in the late '70s was more rigorous than this dog's breakfast, at least prior to the calculus (where I don't like the emphasis on "Working within contexts whenever possible..."). Note that the word "proof" doesn't appear until the very highest specific class; traditionally the geometry class after the first algebra class was where that was introduced. Then again, if they're preparing students for Harvard, as of the late '80s the only math requirement there was to prove you could do algebra, according to a friend who took their honors calculus.
- tokenadult 17y agoSo you think these are easy problems? What would be an example of a secondary math curriculum that is better?
- hga 17y agoWell, for starters, the old traditional one that focused on math and not calculators (beyond graphing; being able to quickly turn an equation into a graph is useful, particularly for the calculus). I personally found the Algebra I, Geometry and Algebra II sequence to be good. Algebra I teaches you symbolic math. Geometry teaches you geometry, analogs to algebra (the algebraic discoveries of the Greeks were done with geometry) and introduces you to formal math including proofs. Algebra II brings it all together with serious analytic geometry and more algebra (and hopefully includes matrices); you need a really strong foundation in both to master the calculus. After that, briefly do enough trig to be prepared for calculus (see related comment below) and finish up your pre-calculus ending with limits. At that point I draw an arbitrary line ending secondary math, although of course that's not how it's done, especially in the rest of the world. Things NOT to do: Avoiding "drill and practice". "hands-on labs that require [ Algebra I students ] to collect data, make conjectures, and draw conclusions" Actually, their "ADVANCED INTEGRATED MATHEMATICS" doesn't sound at all bad, except that the binomial theorem is something you should have learned early in Algebra I. It probably is a much better way to introduce trig, which it deadly dry and apparently pointless in the traditional sequence. Back to the things that set off warning bells: An "inductive approach to calculus". "Working within contexts whenever possible" (the emphasis suggests to me that they aren't just doing the standard physics applications).
- tokenadult 17y agoI personally found the Algebra I, Geometry and Algebra II sequence to be good. What textbooks did you use to learn those subjects? If I remember correctly from other comments of yours, you went on to a rigorous quantitative major in college, right?
- hga 17y agoI'm sorry, but that was in the period of 1975-8, so there's not a chance in the world I could remember them. And I went on to be a Chemistry major at MIT ... but everyone at MIT must pass the first four classes listed here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1107911 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1107911 (the calculus plus physics as of the 19th century). My advice is to find older textbooks (used is cheap). Pre-calculator is good (cheap non-graphing calculators were available long before the graphing ones were), avoid New Math and all that like the plague (yes, set theory is tremendously useful (and multiple bases even more for people like us), and I'm very glad I started learning it in elementary school, but for 99% of students it's going to be a totally unmotivated distraction then (I was lucky I found it "neat" and simple to learn)). Rainforest Math is right out, as it anything that doesn't assume you've drilled your arithmetic tables until you know them cold. People have said good things about the Singapore Math curriculum (http://www.singaporemath.com/ http://www.singaporemath.com/) but I haven't really looked at it. Others like the Saxon math texts (http://saxonpublishers.hmhco.com/en/saxonpublishers.htm;jsessionid=CDB48C7E0E7010591B28AE3BF45EE04F.ecom-app-wk2 http://saxonpublishers.hmhco.com/en/saxonpublishers.htm;jses...), which integrate geometry throughout. Avoid anything with manipulatives. (Side note: DO NOT try algebra based physics (generally taught as a US senior class); it's cargo cult science and no one does it but "educators" and their victims. There's a reason Newton invented the integral calculus to figure out his system of mechanics.) I've procured some texts to someday relearn my math starting with Algebra; I can only vouch for the beginning of the first ones and not for someone learning this for the first time; I haven't touched in detail any beyond those two. If you're interested, just ask and I'll supply the list with ISBNs.
- tokenadult 17y ago
- quant18 17y agoAll of the links on that page give me a "system cannot find the file specified" error, except the Harkness one. I assume they were working four hours ago, based on the comments here ... (must resist urge to spout conspiracy theories). They were also working 18 months ago, for anyone who still wants to see them: http://web.archive.org/web/20080610161827/http://math.exeter.edu/dept/materials/index.html http://web.archive.org/web/20080610161827/http://math.exeter... Anyway, based on the dates, I'm guessing this may be some kind of summer/remedial course, rather than their regular curriculum.
- tokenadult 17y agoI'm encountering the same error in not finding the files, which I had previously downloaded. Thanks for the helpful archive link. As of the last revision date, those problem sets were the usual study materials for the main school year math courses at Exeter. Even very advanced students took the courses shown (depending on entry grade) before going on to other courses.