4 ms·
Give them a break. Most academic researchers don't have any motivation to "trap" people using sneaky tactics like that. Furthermore, a lot of people in academia
by dheera 11y ago
Give them a break. Most academic researchers don't have any motivation to "trap" people using sneaky tactics like that. Furthermore, a lot of people in academia are pretty oblivious to the nuisances between the mind-boggling variety of software licences out there.
I'm not saying it's right to be oblivious, but more than likely some poor sleepless grad student is more worried about his/her thesis, graduating, and getting the whole algorithm published in a journal, having lots of people use it and cite her/him, than trapping and suing people. Doing sneaky stuff on purpose would reflect very poorly on the student, professor, research group, and institution.
If this were the work of a startup, I would have a different opinion, but coming out of UCLA, I'd highly, highly, highly doubt they are deliberately trying to trap you.
Send them a comment on Github and gently remind them to provide licence information.
- thebouv 11y agoThey did provide a license. Research purposes only. Explicit license must be obtained for commercial use directly from UCLA. I don't think it is a trap either. I think it is exactly what their department's legal advisor told them to put on there or is boilerplate they even put in a printed document of the algorithm or any research paper. It doesn't need more than that just because it is open source and it doesn't need a well-known OSS license either. Now, I hope they DO go with a more detailed license that is "more" OSS friendly.
- dheera 11y ago"from UCLA". That might mean the researchers intend to apply for a patent on behalf of the university via their technology licensing office or similar, because most universities don't permit individuals to apply for patents solely in their name for research done using university resources. Whether or not the university actually wants to pursue the patent application it is another story. It's conceivable that they may want to use said patent to spin-off a startup or do something else with it. However, I agree with you that I do not think it is a trap. As a general rule it's very, very bad to be sneaky in academia and once you publish anything it's pretty standard that you should be open about your intentions regarding already-published work.