3 ms·
> "There is no Fourth Amendment violation, because Houston had no reasonable expectation of privacy in video footage recorded by a camera that was located on to
by tzs 11y ago
> "There is no Fourth Amendment violation, because Houston had no reasonable expectation of privacy in video footage recorded by a camera that was located on top of a public utility pole and that captured the same views enjoyed by passersby on public roads", Judge John Rogers wrote for the unanimous court [...]
There are two big differences between passersby and unobtrusive fixed cameras.
• Passersby are generally easily noticeable.
• Passersby pass by.
A level of care that would make one safe with a high probability against being seen by passersby might fail completely against unobtrusive fixed cameras, so I'm not sure that the passersby-could-see standard should be the one used for cameras.
For example at a house my family had when I was a kid we were out in the country in a flat valley. From the end of our driveway I could see far enough up and down the road to see any potential passersby a minute away and postpone anything sensitive I wanted to do in the front yard until they had passed by.
On the other hand, I suppose that even if we decide not to allow law enforcement to use unobtrusive fixed cameras in situations like this it won't stop private parties from using them. Any private property that has a view into your private property could be a place where someone has decided to do some video voyeurism and is recoding.
Maybe the technological cat is out of the bag and we are just going to have to accept that if you don't want something seen you need to do it somewhere where there is no visibility from anywhere outside your property.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago3. Passersby don't do so from the top of public utility poles. >Maybe the technological cat is out of the bag and we are just going to have to accept that if you don't want something seen you need to do it somewhere where there is no visibility from anywhere outside your property. Can we just skip the song and dance and say that privacy is only for those who can afford it?
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoThere's another big difference as well - Passersby have distinct, human-fallible memory, while fixed cameras can have the information they record stored and combined. There's a gigantic difference between having a bunch of people see you in various places as you go about your day, and a searchable database of every place your face has been seen in public over the last two years.
- superuser2 11y agoAre you suggesting we legislate which thoughts and observations people are and aren't permitted to record and share?
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoNo, but I am suggesting which databases people should or should not be able to make. Or more specifically, which databases the police should or should not be able to make and access. "Who was seen where and when" isn't particularly privacy-violating. It's the search capability that is. This is especially true when it's targeted at a particular person - I'm not that worried about the police finding people who were in a particular area at a particular time. They've had that power for a long time, through canvassing and other traditional detective work. What I'm worried about is giving them the new ability to quickly and cheaply compile a list of everywhere someone has been and when.
- poopchute 11y agoRe: passer by passes by If someone walks past my house, no problem. If someone sets up a telescope at the end of my driveway to look in my living room, I'm calling the cops.