3 ms·
They are legitimate in the sense that the answer affects the probability of success of the investment. The legality of similar questions in the context of a job
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
They are legitimate in the sense that the answer affects the probability of success of the investment. The legality of similar questions in the context of a job interview is an irrelevant red herring, not sure why you brought it up.
To see why this is a problem, think about the questions in the equally-valid context of a man. Are you planning to have kids? What if your wife has to move for work one day? Will go you with him?
They are perfectly legitimate questions for a man as well. The only reason they aren't asked is because the probability of a negative answer is lower for a man than for a woman.
Similarly, I'm often asked (on job interviews) "do you plan to return to academia?" You are probably not asked this (unless you are a former academic), since the odds of you pursuing an academic career are much lower than mine.
Incidentally, if you were a new stay at home daddy, I probably wouldn't give you VC either.
- tptacek 17y agoYou demonstrated to your potential employer that you're interested in pursuing a career in academia. The potential employer is generalizing from your own past behavior. That's why it's lawful for the employer to ask about your academic proclivities, but flatly unlawful for them to ask women about family planning. I think you summed your position up nicely with your last sentence ("... if you were a new stay at home daddy, I probably wouldn't give you VC either"), since we're not actually talking about new mothers. We're talking about an entire gender, and the generalizations you're OK with making about them.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI'm not making a generalization. I'm making a probabilistic statement. P(me vanishing into academia) >> P(you vanishing into academia). That's why they ask me but not you. P(woman vanishing into mommyland) >> P(man vanishing into daddyland). That's why they ask women but not men. As for legality of employers, who cares? A) Legality != legitimacy. B) We are talking about VCs doing their due diligence with their client's money (e.g., my pension fund), so the legality of employers asking such questions is irrelevant.
- tptacek 17y agoYou have no idea what the probability of a woman startup founder "vanishing into mommyhood" is. Your own behavior makes you more likely to vanish into academia. Your analysis is overtly sexist. What's great about your logic is you can use it to justify any discriminatory conduct. P(academia)? Hey, then P(black person)! They're much more likely to end up in prison, statistically!
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI have no idea what the probability of a male startup founder vanishing into daddyhood is either. So I'm estimating it with the best available information, namely the relative probabilities of people in general. Similarly, people who assume I'll vanish back into academia don't know the probability of this (it's actually quite low, due to the way the academic job market works), but they are making a best guess. Also, my logic doesn't justify anything unless the estimated probabilities are large enough. Is P(jail | black ) anywhere near as large as P(misses work due to baby | woman)? Somehow I doubt it. In any case, I'd really like it if you could explain the sexism in my analysis. Specifically, tell me how my conclusions change if you replace gender with other characteristics yielding similar probabilities. Or are we supposed to pay attention to all probabilistically relevant characteristics except for gender?