4 ms·
I feel the opposite. Some of the blame here can be placed with Apple and their idiotic handling of the App Store. If the App Store wasn't such a shitty place to
by mikeash 11y ago
I feel the opposite. Some of the blame here can be placed with Apple and their idiotic handling of the App Store. If the App Store wasn't such a shitty place to sell apps, many of these app could have been there and used Apple's presumably-secure update mechanism rather than rolling their own. What good are security benefits if you can't make money selling your product there?
- acdha 11y agoThis matches everything I've read from Mac developers – the App Store would be a great idea except for the arbitrary impediments to having a viable business. Michael Tsai had a good roundup of just how widespread that trend's becoming and how it's driven by only a few issues like the inability to do paid upgrades and the slow review process: http://mjtsai.com/blog/2015/12/01/sketch-leaving-the-mac-app-store/ http://mjtsai.com/blog/2015/12/01/sketch-leaving-the-mac-app... I really wish the Mac App Store was more like Yum/APT where you have a single update mechanism with baked-in mandatory security but otherwise leave publishing up to the actual developers. If Apple wants to have a curated store with reviews, etc. that's fine but it's just not viable as the only option for every class of application.
- mikeash 11y agoThere's some additional irony in that apps can be sandboxed even when distributed outside the App Store, and many of these apps could function fine within the sandbox... except for Sparkle, which needs more access! And there's no particular reason everything in the App Store must be sandboxed. It used to not be required, then Apple changed the rules. Sandboxing helps with security, but for this particular question of a vulnerable app updater, simply using the App Store's update mechanism would suffice to make it safe, even for non-sandboxed apps.
- acdha 11y agoI wish they had a two-tier approach: have the current reviewed thing as a sort of Apple-preferred gold star kind of deal but allow other apps to be listed relying on customer reviews, and maybe some sort of warning that this hasn't been audited as much, etc. Besides the reliable updater, it'd be really nice just for them to be able to flip the kill-switch on known-exploitable apps ASAP when something bad happens.