4 ms·
Is Donald Trump a fascist? A historian of fascism weighs in
- wmil 11y agoThere's a famous joke that "fascist" in politics just means "I don't like you" It's just an ill-defined insult at this point. George Orwell had interesting things to say. http://orwell.ru/library/articles/As_I_Please/english/efasc http://orwell.ru/library/articles/As_I_Please/english/efasc
- hnhg 11y agoI've seen more than a handful of presumably right-wing commentators on Reddit of late arguing that the Nazis were actually socialists or 'communists' rather than a right-wing group. The ensuing (typically unresolved) argument comes down to how fascism is defined for each person. Fascism is clearly in the eye of the beholder.
- x0ra 11y ago"Nazi" actually stands for "Nationalsozialismus", or in plain English, National Socialism.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- venomsnake 11y agoNazi is national socialism. Fascism was in Italy and Spain.
- ooo000ooo 11y agoSpain's (and Portugal's) case was more of a traditionalist, catholic thing. Franco just appropriated the imaginery of the falangist party, then proceed to do what he wanted. Which was autocracy at first and, when it didn't work, technocracy. That did indeed work and built Spain's middle class.
- djmdjm 11y agoThe Nazi party was socialist in much the same way the DPRK is democratic.
- gozur88 11y agoWeird that they put the word in the name of the party when they didn't know what it means.
- dang 11y agoThey knew what it meant. I think putting that word in the name was a cheap way of appealing to the disaffected working class early on.
- Grue3 11y agoIt wasn't all that different from Soviet Union back then. Or current DPRK for that matter.
- codesushi42 11y agoWrong. Hitler had great admiration of Mussolini all the way up to Mussolini's death. Hitler copied Mussolini (including the Roman salute) and used Italy's dictatorship as a model for Germany's. Fascism in Spain didn't come until after fascism took over both Italy and Germany, and only did with the help of both of those countries. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Guernica https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombing_of_Guernica
- osullivj 11y agoAnd Mussolini copied it all from Gabriele D'Annunzio's irredentist Regency of Carnaro in Fiume 1919-20 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_Regency_of_Carnaro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_Regency_of_Carnaro
- ry_ry 11y agoI don't think the political spectrum is a simple straight line, as the traditional left-center-right labels would imply. If you travel far enough along that line, extreme politics of either flavour will for all practical purposes converge. If not in ideology, then implementation.
- duncanawoods 11y agoIt was an evolution. The party started as an anti-capitalist worker's party with a left-wing manifesto and parts of the party wanted to collaborate with the communist party. However, Hitler jettisoned the left-wing aspects, cozied up to the capitalists and aristocrats to fund the growth of the party and reshaped the party inspired by Mussolini's fascists. The early socialist manifestos were an embarrassment for the party as it grew and it never attempted any of what that early party sought like disbanding the army, expropriating land from owners etc. Here is the the early manifesto. The only thing recognisable from what the Nazi party eventually became is the anti-semitism: http://www.scrapbookpages.com/DachauScrapbook/25Points.html http://www.scrapbookpages.com/DachauScrapbook/25Points.html
- osullivj 11y agoQuite correct. Goebbels was on the left wing of the party originally, but was ultimately a Hitler loyalist. The Night of the Long Knives in June 34, and the killing of Ernst Roehm, was all about the purging of any threats from the the left wing of the party.
- patrickburke 11y agoThe terms right-wing and left-wing are as meaningless as the term fascism.
- dba7dba 11y agoDuel between fascist versus socialist in the upcoming presidential election?
- empath75 11y agoHe says that he thinks trump never read a book on Hitler, but he at least owned a book of his speeches, according to his ex wife.
- onion2k 11y agoOwning a book and reading it are two different things. We all own books we've never read.
- jacquesm 11y agoWhy on earth would you own a book you've never read?
- venomsnake 11y agoIt was gifted to him IIRC.
- qrendel 11y agoBecause you haven't gotten around to it yet but plan on reading it eventually. Or just because you want to signal status by publicly displaying your bookshelf.
- onion2k 11y agoI tell myself I'll get around reading them eventually. Although the backlog well is in to the hundreds now, so I don't imagine I actually will.
- caf 11y agoThere's a word for it: tsundoku
- ionised 11y agoI've bought around 8 or 9 books in the last few months and haven't read any of them yet. They go on my bookshelf until I'm done with my current reading. I tend to read them in chronological order of purchase.
- vmorgulis 11y agoHe looks like the bad guy in Dead Zone: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dead_Zone_%28film%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dead_Zone_%28film%29 But he is more a populist than a facist.
- jakeogh 11y agoSetting aside Mr. Trump... "The trends are not downward unless you were offended by the presence of a black man in the White House."[3] Except we are still expected to live in a 'post-911'[1] state[2] of fear. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQu_mYI3Vxs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQu_mYI3Vxs [2] https://cryptome.org/2015/09/potus-15-0911.pdf https://cryptome.org/2015/09/potus-15-0911.pdf [3] Wow. Talk about painting the people you disagree with.
- codesushi42 11y agoAgreed. Populist candidates like Trump and Sanders have as much clout as they do exactly because the country is in decline. And the public is tired of the elitist run media telling them otherwise. The harder the media pushes their delusional reality, the harder the public pushes back, and the stronger Trump becomes. Not that I hope for such a thing. But it's entertaining to see the media's propaganda continue to backfire on them. And they act totally oblivious as to why.
- notliketherest 11y agoThe things Donald Trump says (such as "stop Mexicans from coming into our country illegally" or "ban Muslims from immigrating to our country until we're confident in our terrorist screening process") offend a LOT of people. People who don't believe such things should be said, or even talked about. People who, when someone says these things, viciously attack them, saying they are morally wrong for thinking those things. People that band together as a group to silence those who dare utter what they deem "inappropriate" or "politically incorrect" or "shouldn't be said, it's racist!" In other words, I'd argue that Donald Trump, rather than being a fascist, is a reaction against fascists. Liberal fascists who squash the dissent against their group think with social media lynch mobbing.
- ArtDev 11y agoIts not the racism, the misogynistic comments or the xenophobia. Its the power trip. Its how he treats people directly. For example: http://www.businessinsider.com/donald-trump-protester-roughed-up-2015-11 http://www.businessinsider.com/donald-trump-protester-roughe...
- hnhg 11y agoYou're misusing the word fascist. You probably mean something more like 'hard-liners' or 'extremist'.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- drewrv 11y agoThis is just the Tolerance Paradox. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance Except not really. There's no movement on the left to outlaw what trump is saying. Pointing out something is racist on twitter is not "squashing dissent".
- empressplay 11y agoErm, people have been trying to get him tossed off Twitter [1] and banned from entering various countries [2] and apparently some of his most vocal supporters have had their Twitter accounts mysteriously locked-out [3] [1] http://tech.slashdot.org/story/16/01/30/1847207/why-does-twitter-refuse-to-shut-down-donald-trump http://tech.slashdot.org/story/16/01/30/1847207/why-does-twi... [2] http://thevine.com.au/politics/australians-want-ban-donald-trump-entering-country/ http://thevine.com.au/politics/australians-want-ban-donald-t... [3] http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2016/02/08/twitters-attempt-to-silence-generation-trump/ http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2016/02/08/twitters-attempt-to...
- dang 11y agoThis is a political story, but it's also unusually interesting in HN's sense, so we've exempted it from the usual penalties. If you're going to comment, please be sure you're doing so out of intellectual curiosity, the guiding value of this site. Partisan boosting and bashing is off topic. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- qrendel 11y agoObligatory: http://www.alternet.org/files/story_images/bo151216.png http://www.alternet.org/files/story_images/bo151216.png
- FrankenPC 11y agoThat's genius!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wbillingsley 11y ago"Hello, editor, I've got this great idea for an article on the presidential race -- I'd like to do something serious; you know, not one of those fluffy hatchet jobs or gotchas, but really get some proper perspective and analysis and delve deep into the heart of the issue. I think our readership would really appreciate us respecting their intelligence, their judgment, and laying out the different sides of the argument, and all the facts in all their detail. Let the reader make up their own mind, rather than just seeing the same old biased spin. Sorry, what's that? What the issue is? Oh, yes, I'd like to write something really serious and analytical on whether this politician I don't like is dumber than a day-old turd."
- ranko 11y agoFascinating stuff. As ever, the answer is "it's complicated". We can see Trump adopting (presumably unconsciously) some of the tropes of fascism; the business with the plane, for example. This doesn't, of course, make him a fascist in itself. I suspect that he would qualify as an authoritarian nationalist on some level, but whether he is interested in the kind of martial law usually associated with fascism seems less certain to me.
- codesushi42 11y agoThe plane example was a weak cherry pick in a weak article overall. Trump is a bigot, but it's too early to say whether he's a fascist. FDR forced Japanese citizens into internment camps, but history does not remember him as a fascist. I'm not being an apologist for Trump's comments. But they're just not enough to classify him as a fascist. If he advocates for more foreign wars, additions to the Patriot Act, or nationalizing entire industries, then we're getting warmer. Though, maybe he can claim one or two of those.
- SRSposter 11y agoHilarious
- joesmo 11y agoAren't racist, sexist, and xenophobic enough? Because I'm sure I can think of plenty more adjectives that I can apply objectively. I disagree with the article that 'fascist' is one of the worst things to be in today's world and those three things above (as well as the rest that could've gone there) are much worse.
- venomsnake 11y agoNot at all. Calling something or someone racist, sexist or xenophobic does not by itself means much or invalidate. A policy may be such and still effective or optimal. Lets take Europe migration crisis - 70% of the incoming people are single, young and male - that is the demographic that is impossible to integrate and they skew gender balance which is sure way to create social tension. A policy to exclude them and only let women, children and families will be all of those 3 (and couple more isms), but i think it will lead to better outcome for Europe than the current situation.
- vlehto 11y agoThe essential difference between totalitarian state and military junta seems to be popular support. With junta, you can trust that almost nobody is loyal directly to the dictator, they just want money and stay alive. So you can bribe anybody. In totalitarian state you can never be sure who will take "cause of the party" as his own. So lives of normal people are affected in totally different way. There has been two types of totalitarian popular movements so far: nationalistic and international. Fascism falls in the first category, Communism in the second. The problem of communist is that it never has been able to spread the revolution as originally intended. So they have fallen back to "Socialism in one state" policies everywhere. Given the similarities, it's not surprising that the left usually tries to paint fascism as "far right" or "ultra nationalist". The first is simply incorrect, the latter on the other hand is kinda misleading. Nationalism is also the basis for all systems of national governance, so you can be ultra nationalist while supporting democracy, monarchy or pretty much anything else. Even Stalinism when that dude was still alive.
- venomsnake 11y agoCouple of thoughts: The greatest relative strength of USA was right after the WWII when US GDP and industrial capacity was more than the rest of the world combined, had unmatched military capability and nuclear supremacy. Since then in geopolitical terms US is in decline. The peak of US economy looking from the point of the middle class was 1969 - after that there were oil shocks, stagflation, outsourcing and hollowing out of the middle class. with a short blip upwards in the late 90s when US was reaping the benefits of winning the cold war and the computing boom. And right now US is in a almost decade long depression if you exclude the SV,Wall street, and some landlords. So there is both relative and real decline for big parts of the US public. I don't think Trump is a fascist. Or even a particularly authoritarian hard liner. And he has so far respected the letter of the US constitution. All of his vitriol has been towards people that are not US citizens. And the Supreme Court has made it clear that if you are not a US Citizen being in US is privilege, not a right.
- tomp 11y agoIt's funny how many people oppose Trump on the basis of his "Mexican wall" idea, while supporting Hillary. Meanwhile, the "Mexican wall" already exists (Google it!), and Hillary voted for it: > I voted numerous times when I was a senator to spend money to build a barrier to try to prevent illegal immigrants from coming in http://www.latintimes.com/hillary-clinton-bragging-about-building-border-wall-keeping-out-illegal-immigrants-352631 http://www.latintimes.com/hillary-clinton-bragging-about-bui...
- sbardle 11y agoTrump doesn't believe in anything, but he is mining the writing of the paleoconservative movement (the traditional right) for popular appeal.
- dba7dba 11y agoTrump is not a fascist. No way He is a narcist. He spent like first 8 minutes of his first speech after winning New Hampshire saying things like I love you. You love me. I have lots of money. You love me. Actually Hitler was a narcist so maybe Trump is a fascist.
- tptacek 11y agoThis article on the Atlantic is, I think, a bit better and more interesting: http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/01/donald-trump-fascist/424449/ http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2016/01/don... (Pretty much the same conclusion, though).