5 ms·
The comments here are a great example of why mental health treatment is such a difficult problem for the tech crowd: Most of the comments are from people who be
by PragmaticPulp 11y ago
The comments here are a great example of why mental health treatment is such a difficult problem for the tech crowd: Most of the comments are from people who believe they have a better handle a mental health diagnosis and treatment than actual psychiatrists, and many of them are quite wrong. Some of them dangerously so.
Depression, anxiety, suicidal ideation, ADHD, and other mental health issues are extremely complex issues that can't be universally explained away by blood sugar or lack of spouses or loneliness as some of commenters here confidently claim. Every case is different, every person has their own complex set of issues and maladaptive coping behaviors and external stressors, and everyone responds to medications and lifestyle changes differently. Perhaps more importantly, navigating all of those individual variations is best left to a close patient-doctor relationship, leveraging each patients' feedback against the doctor's years of clinical experience.
The mistake many people make is trying to map others' mental health disorders on to their own prior experiences. That's why you see so many comments from people confidently declaring that curing depression is as simple as exercising because they felt sad a few years ago but felt better when they started running. That's great, and exercise is likely to help everyone, but that doesn't mean that another person's depression is simply a lack of exercise. Don't ever discount or downplay another person's mental health suffering, because that's only going to make things harder for them. Mental health sufferers often feel significant guilt about their symptoms, and having someone dismiss or downplay their suffering only compounds that.
Modern psychiatry isn't perfect and has plenty of room for improvement, but frankly it's a whole lot better than the comments here make it out to be. If you're struggling with mental health issues, make it a priority to see a professional. Get a second or third opinion if you're not happy with your treatment. But whatever you do, don't get sucked in to the misinformed internet commenters trying to discourage people from seeking treatment. Psychiatry can take some time, but the area under the curve of even marginal mental health improvements can add up to a huge difference over the course of your life.
- milkytron 11y agoYour statements don't only apply to the tech crowd; I feel as though what you just said could easily be pasted across the web to provide a huge amount of help to anyone suffering from symptoms of mental illness. I am no expert, but this certainly helped my understanding of the issue a great deal, and I'm sure it would for others as well.
- phaus 11y agoI'm not saying people in the comments are any good at helping people with mental illnesses, but from my experience the professionals are pretty fucking terrible at it too. I'm autistic and my wife has PTSD and anxiety disorder. She's been through about 6 therapists, all of whom were highly recommended by other people we know or other therapists. We've been to three marriage counsellors. I've been to a therapist that was an "autism specialist" who told me after speaking to me for 3 minutes that I'm not autistic because I have at least 1 friend and I'm married. Perhaps these were all smart people, but between the 10 of them, they have so far been completely unable to help my wife and I with any of our problems. We've been throwing a small fortune at our various issues, and our lives are still a nightmare. I'm even about to pay 10-15k out of pocket for a fucking therapy dog that's probably going to be a waste of money, because we are desperate and the professionals aren't very useful.
- Spiritus 11y agoWhat's the difference between a therapy dog and a regular dog?
- jacalata 11y agoI'm not terribly familiar with them, but in general a therapy dog should have been trained in some way to ameliorate a specific condition - eg, to notice that the owner is approaching a panic attack and alert them with a specific series of barks, or to maintain a touch contact that helps the owner cope with anxiety, etc.
- phaus 11y ago10K+ worth of training. Some people with PTSD claim that having one is life changing.
- lentil_soup 11y agoCan I ask why you think you're autistic if therapists tell you you're not? Or was it just that one?
- 11y ago
- throwawaymaroon 11y agoI don't think it's particular to the tech crowd, and I think it's a stumbling block even for psychiatry. The problem is that psychiatry as practiced is an attempt to solve people, and people can't be solved; or if they can, it is unique (as you say) to the individual. And really you're no different: you're giving out advice to people on how to manage their mental health. Your advice is harmless from a societal perspective in that it's literally what psychiatrists want you to be saying. That doesn't mean you're not one of the misinformed internet commenters. It's not universally applicable. Most people don't have the time and money to shop around, even if the actual problems of their mental state allow them to seek help. You can't come up with the words that are going to make people better. Nor should you be expected to! Recognizing that psychiatrists are the ones we pay to be expected to act to make people better and they are themselves human and subject to human failures: this, I think, is why criticism of psychiatry emerges in topics like these. I'm not disagreeing with your general advice, just criticizing your smugness and certainty in your opening lines. You're not better at this than we are just because you're giving the generic safe advice.
- such_a_casual 11y agoI think the real issue is that whether they are psychologists or psychiatrists, there seems to be no accountability in the field (outside of extremes like malpractice) in terms of whether or not they actually provide any value to the patient. If someone goes to a psychologist for 20 years and at the end of it they're still just as bad as when they started, there's no, "I'd like my money back from the last 20 years". Sometimes a professional might not know if they can help, but even if it becomes obvious to them that this is someone they can't help, they don't say, "I'm unable to help you. Stop being a customer." They just continue down the path. This isn't to say that most mental health professionals are taking people's money without actually doing anything (I have no idea if that's the case), but rather it's difficult for the patient to know if they are actually getting any help, it is difficult for the patient to hold the person accountable if they don't get the help they expected, and it is difficult for the patient to even know if they're right or wrong about the matter (since they are not the expert). This makes it easy for the patient to doubt and blame the mental health professional or the entire field, there's just so much grey area.
- bcarlyle 11y agoI'm a clinical psychologist who was in charge of the largest randomized controlled trial of online cognitive behavioral therapy for depression (n=500). There is nothing that annoys me more then the every person is a special snowflake argument for why we can't use standardized treatment for mental health problem. Exercise works really well for curing depression. I talked to a depressed patient yesterday who had no idea what he could do to combat his depression. I finally convinced him that if he couldn't think of anything else to do he should just try going for a walk and he told me later that it really helped. I've had that exact conversation a hundred times. Almost all patients I meet have the faulty belief that they are special. That they function in a way that is different from others and that often make them resist treatment. Your head is connected to your physical body and therefore we can figure out what helps for everyone in the same way a doctor knows what to do about a broken foot. Did you know that almost half off patients who suffer from anxiety take too shallow breaths and this creates respiratory alkalosis that creates a lot of the anxiety symptoms. Did you know that by breathing calmly you will cure yourself from panic attacks? Forever. Did you know that psychologists know how to cure insomnia in a single session? The biggest hurdle to overcome is the idea that there exists a magic barrier where your disorder goes from being something that you can cure yourself to something you need a professional for. The barrier is an illusion. You always have the power to change your mood for the better. I'm not saying that therapy isn't useful. It is extremely useful and helps people tremendously. I'm saying that every single individual can make a conscious effort to focus on improving their mental health irregardless of the fact that they are seeing a therapist. Also. Almost every single person is illiterate about how to treat mental health problems. I've been a fairly happy person all my life and I believe I owe it to the fact that I developed excellent coping mechanisms. If you haven't got those you need to learn them. Once you have them it gets much easier to have good mental health. I'm actually working on building free online treatment for depression right now. It is a work in progress but if anyone is interested they can check it out here. https://getpsychologistsnow.com/cbt/depression/ https://getpsychologistsnow.com/cbt/depression/
- nikmobi 11y ago> Did you know that psychologists know how to cure insomnia in a single session? Can you please elaborate more on this point? :)