3 ms·
You might be just as fast and just as accurate but your fingers are definitely working harder, which could lead to RSI, for example. People have analyzed variou
by melling 11y ago
You might be just as fast and just as accurate but your fingers are definitely working harder, which could lead to RSI, for example. People have analyzed various layouts for efficiency, which may vary with type of work:
http://xahlee.info/kbd/dvorak_and_all_keyboard_layouts.html http://xahlee.info/kbd/dvorak_and_all_keyboard_layouts.html
http://patorjk.com/keyboard-layout-analyzer/#/about http://patorjk.com/keyboard-layout-analyzer/#/about
https://medium.com/@vojtajina/my-keyboard-layout-is-better-than-yours-f23b19d1b046 https://medium.com/@vojtajina/my-keyboard-layout-is-better-t...
There are more links under "Alternate Keyboard Layouts" on this GitHub page: https://github.com/melling/ErgonomicNotes/blob/master/keyboards.org https://github.com/melling/ErgonomicNotes/blob/master/keyboa...
- mchahn 11y ago> which could lead to RSI As a single data-point I find RSI isn't a problem for my typing style. I'm in my sixties and I've fought RSI on and off many times. To the contrary my typing style has changed to be more comfortable and less stressful. I've actually had to change it at times to lessen pains in specific fingers. Forcing myself to use touch-typing had caused pain in my pinkies before.
- melling 11y agoWhat is your "typing style"? Newer keyboard layouts trying to reduce the "pinky" usage. "Programmer Dvorak", for instance, places frequently use programming keys (e.g. [ }) more conveniently on the keyboard. What you're doing might work for you, but there are quite a few people with RSI issues so something that helps and is reproducible is needed.
- mchahn 11y agoI use only qwerty. I've never considered another. Studies say dvorak is no faster and I've never considered it for pain. > What you're doing might work for you, As I said, it's just one data point.
- melling 11y agoIt's not about typing faster, it's about moving your fingers less by placing frequently used keys on the home row, or in an easier place to reach. I posted a lot of information about this. Read through some of it. Think about it like mileage on a car. If your fingers move half the distance to type the same text, that will add up over the decades.
- nrinaudo 11y agoI've actually given dvorak a fair shot - used it exclusively for a complete year, bought a blind keyboard to speed up learning, practiced daily with dedicated tools for the first month or so. I also took the opportunity to learn proper typing style, rather than a sort of 9 fingered hunt and peck system I had fallen into. The result is absolute, abject failure. More pain in the wrist and upper arm and noticeable reduction of work efficiency. I'm now back to qwerty and hands flying over the keyboard. I've however come to the conclusion that it's not specific to dvorak, but rather an inherent flaw of the "proper" way of typing, at least when it applies to programming, at least when it comes to the way I do it: I'm using the arrow keys rather a lot, especially since I don't ever use a mouse to navigate in text. The arrow keys are far enough of the "main" part of the keyboard that I can't reach them without moving my right hand away from the proper, F-J position. Getting it back to the right position afterwards often involves a bit of fumbling, to the point where I sometime shift it one entire column to the right and need to delete the 5 or 6 characters I typed before my brain caught up with what was happening. This is both frustrating and, over the course of a long day, exhausting. I know that there are solutions for this: I could use emacs-like shortcuts to navigate (ctrl-n for ->, say), I could use fancy keyboards such as the typematrix which map the arrow keys to cleverly choosen normal keys with a FN modifier... but at this point, I just want to be able to type comfortably again, not learn yet another alien (to me) method of typing in the hopes that in a year or two, I'll be back to where I was one year ago.