3 ms·
I feel like this has already been real-world tested, and manual sorting loses to algorithms. Facebook had categories or lists (can't remember what they called t
by snowwrestler 11y ago
I feel like this has already been real-world tested, and manual sorting loses to algorithms. Facebook had categories or lists (can't remember what they called them) and few people used them. Google+ had the "circles" as a key differentiator vs. Facebook, and it did not help them compete at all.
I think social media lists are one of those ideas that seems great in theory, but whose value is dynamically unstable in real life.
Lists are only valuable if they are well-maintained. But maintainence takes time and attention, which are not always available. And once lists start to be compromised, even a little, then it will take even more time and attention to fix them. Which makes it even more unlikely they'll be fixed.
Obviously lists work for you, but it seems like they don't for most folks.
- infogulch 11y agoSo if the problem with lists is that they require effort to maintain them, how about lists with algorithmic maintenance suggestions? People that are hands-off can leave it fully automatic, whereas others could still make use of suggestions to maintain their fine-tuned lists more easily.
- argonaut 11y agoStill requires effort to maintain. You have to click to add friends. Take a page from Facebook. It's now really hard to manage lists; they encourage you to use automatically-generated lists, though. I'm sure they had reams of data to support this (over the objections of vocal power users).
- wcummings 11y agoEmail is usually sorted manually, I think.
- snowwrestler 11y agoPeople hate managing their email, in my experience. What was Gmail's original value proposition? You never have to worry about deleting or filing emails anymore, because you get a ton of space and really good search. I know a lot of people do carefully file their emails, but Gmail shipped without folders at all and they've done well with that model.
- tyre 11y agoThat said, their priority inbox is amazing. Automatically sorting into Primary, Social, Promotions, Updates, and Social helps me manage my day. Automated, curated lists are great. Manual ones (e.g. folders) just add more for me to do.
- jchendy 11y agoDoes anybody know how Multireddits are working out? I personally use them extensively, but I've never seen any data on how successful they've been overall.
- geostyx 11y agoThe only multireddit I ever use is the top 100 nsfw subs one...
- lukewrites 11y ago(If I could edit my original post, I'd change "better off" to "should also". I didn't mean to say that the use of lists and an algorithmic news feed is an either-or proposition.) I agree with you, and think your examples from fb and G+ are compelling. Anything that adds entropy for the user is a hard-if-not-impossible sell. In reflecting on all this, I realized I like lists because they make twitter useful. News feeds, by contrast, make social media entertaining. So: where do the twain meet? I'd suggest two models: "smart" lists and curated lists. A real world example of smart lists would be feedly. When I add an RSS feed to my account, feedly suggests a category for it. I'd say the suggested categories are accurate 80%+ of the time. If twitter were to implement this so when you follow someone twitter automatically suggests a list you could add the person to, it would both benefit the follower (I have topic-based lists I can look at, and I didn't have to do anything!) and the person being followed (hey, I got a new follower!). Curated lists could be straight up useful (list-lover that I am, I subscribe to some other users' lists). With the advent of Moments, it's clear twitter is open to curation; how about encouraging individual to provide curated lists? I don't think that twitter will go the way of focusing on lists, but I think there could be significant value in simply making lists a bit more prominent.