2 ms·
Unfortunately, I think the peer review idea, which is great, is starting to break down. The latest news item that makes me sketical is the Lancet/autism piece,
by mistermann 17y ago
Unfortunately, I think the peer review idea, which is great, is starting to break down. The latest news item that makes me sketical is the Lancet/autism piece, and then this article.
When did the common culture in the science start that "authorities" on a subject could release studies and criticism was not allowed?
I'll fully admit that I'm not qualified to judge the merits of most of these things, but in the past, scientists were excited to explain their findings to skeptics...now, they seem to want to change the subject away from findiings. Maybe I'm just old fashioned.
- hga 17y agoWell ... while The Lancet is in theory peer reviewed, it has had a very poor reputation for a long time. Anyone who takes what it publishes without a large grain of salt deserves what they get. (Unfortunately in this case, by trashing herd immunity they've killed quite a few children with e.g. measles (yes, you can name names with a little Google fu).)