5 ms·
I got to > Our results suggest that although women on GitHub may be more competent overall and stopped. No. Just, no. I'm inclined to disbelieve any study th
by kstrauser 11y ago
I got to
> Our results suggest that although women on GitHub may be more competent overall
and stopped. No. Just, no. I'm inclined to disbelieve any study that claims one gender is better at programming than other, and that claim makes me automatically dismiss the rest of its conclusions.
- StavrosK 11y agoYou're being downvoted, but what if the result was "Our results suggest that although men on GitHub may be more competent overall"? Then you'd probably be upvoted. Also, I refuse to believe that genders are obviously different in various physiological and mental traits (e.g. height, spatial awareness, ability to host a baby) except the ones that are socially uncomfortable to us.
- mucker 11y agoNo, that is very unlikely.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kstrauser 11y agoI suspect you're right about the first part. That makes me sad, because I'd hope we'd be more even-keeled as a community. I haven't seen any evidence that the second is true, though. I've not heard of a plausible mechanism by which - all else equal - men would be better at abstract reasoning than women or vice versa.
- StavrosK 11y agoI haven't seen any evidence that it's false, though, either, and there are obviously physical and mental differences between sexes/races/whatever, so it seems more likely to me that this would follow the rule, rather than be the exception.
- mucker 11y agoWhy? Brain structure is different there might be other real differences. However, the data doesn't show that at all. It merely shows acceptance is higher. I am therefore left wondering are these non-controversial changes? For example, how many of these are documentation changes?
- throwawayaway 11y agoTheorizing is fine, to say: 'Maybe because of barriers to entry, only the stronger programmers survive, from that follows the higher acceptance rate'. It's just information but you are right in saying that they should not be making any claims or drawing conclusions! Also I casually give the wrong gender on websites because on the internet nobody should care. Look! Somebody wrote an essay about a similar phenomenon: http://paulgraham.com/bias.html http://paulgraham.com/bias.html
- bcook 11y agoSo we are absolutely equal and any conclusion otherwise is false?
- kstrauser 11y agoI don't know if that's true, but I haven't heard a viable explanation about why the opposite would be plausible, either. I'm not a neuroscientist, but I don't know of any reasons why one gender would be better at mental tasks than another.
- themagician 11y agoSee, I'm inclined to believe it. If for no other reason than it just seems intuitive. Women who go into technology know it's an uphill battle. They work that much harder and honestly I'd expect their work to be better, on average, particularly for open source projects because they are genuinely interested in improving the code. They always have to contend with the thought, "Will people reject this because I'm a woman? Better make sure it's as good as it possibly can be so they can't reject it based on that."
- dudul 11y agoNot sure I understand. So men in OSS are not genuinely interested in improving the code?
- irremediable 11y agoOf course they are. But if there is significant discrimination against women, maybe women either get really good or leave OSS/programming altogether. Leading to the remaining women (the sample) being "more competent".
- larsiusprime 11y agoThe argument seems to be mathematical, not categorical, this is what I think is being claimed -- "there are many more men on github than women, thus there is stronger selection pressures on the women who are on github. Whether men are more or less competent than women IN GENERAL is a separate question from which is, on average the more competent sub-population on github."
- themagician 11y agoI was trying to find a way to articulate this and failing. This was my intended meaning.
- iLoch 11y agoIt's an interesting hypothesis, but I don't think I agree. The selection pool for women is smaller in STEM, therefore less women means less exceptional women. > particularly for open source projects because they are genuinely interested in improving the code I reject this on the grounds that there's no reason why women would be more interested in improving the code than men. > "Will people reject this because I'm a woman? Better make sure it's as good as it possibly can be so they can't reject it based on that." I'd be surprised to learn that this was the thought process of the majority of women, let alone most of them.
- akerro 11y agoHey, but did you know that white woman are biggest barriers in progressing opens ource projects? https://i.imgur.com/7YaVYUx.jpg https://i.imgur.com/7YaVYUx.jpg <- github conference
- alexpeattie 11y agoI guess competent is meant to be shorthand for "likely to get a Pull Request merged" - I agree that competent is a overextension of that, and very subjective. The actual study is more thoughtful than the abstract might suggest.
- id 11y agoYeah, it is possible that man just overestimate themselves at a higher rate. Or that the women of Github have a solid CS background at a higer rate then the men do. The thing is, we don't really know.
- dibujante 11y agoThen you misunderstand their argument.
- irremediable 11y agoIMO that's a knee-jerk reaction to which you shouldn't succumb. The study isn't saying that "one gender is better at programming"; it's saying there's weak evidence that GitHub users of one gender might be slightly more competent. There are many reasons that might be true without any gender being better programmers in general.
- stormbrew 11y agoYour summary of the claim is not the same as the claim. "Women on github" are not "women in general." There is a well established idea that glass ceiling-type barriers require higher competence from women to push through the barriers holding them back than men face. Though I suspect you'll find the last sentence of this quote off-putting, it's often summarized as the following: > “Whatever women do they must do twice as well as men to be thought half as good. Luckily, this is not difficult.” - Charlotte Whitton.
- ksenzee 11y ago"Women on GitHub" != "women". Nobody is suggesting women are better at programming. The results are showing that women who submit GitHub PRs are more competent. There could be any number of reasons for that: - women are more timid, so they don't even try submitting a PR until they're sure their work is good - less determined women (who would perhaps also be less competent) are turned off by the culture of the industry - women in the industry hide behind gender-neutral profiles until they have more experience
- ashark 11y agoI also wouldn't be surprised if it turned out there's a significant difference in the average age of women on Github, compared with men.
- ustolemyname 11y agoIt doesn't claim that. You're conflating "women on GitHub vs men on github" with "a random sampling of men and women". Given that in the above study there seems to be dramatically fewer women than men contributing to GitHub, take the assumption that in the general population men and women have similar distributions of programming competence, and it seems women are more strongly selected against to contribute on GitHub than men. It seems reasonable that the women who push would have traits associated with greater competence. Thus men and women have equal ability, but women on GitHub can on average be more competent than men on GitHub.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ffn 11y agoActually, if you look at their numbers (or the summary numbers provided by the top-voted comment), the statement "women on github are more competent than men" seems to be a result of selection bias rather than "one sex is better than the other". It appears there are more than 150k men on github but less than 10k women. But if you look at real life, men don't out-number women 15-to-1, which seems to suggest programming on github draws in more men than women. I suggest that, whereas in addition to professional men, tons of boys will make a hobbyist account on github to leave inane comments on open-source projects, there are very few hobbyist girls that fall into this category; that is, a woman only makes an account on github if she is a professional in the industry. Naturally, if you compare a group of professionals against a group of professionals + college-rockstar-ninja-guru-hackathon-"yeah, but is it optimized?" amateurs, the group of professionals without the baggage would be "better". Anyway, that's my take on what the numbers say; maybe I'm wrong, in which case, I for one welcome our new female overlords; if they must put us all to death, may they do so with snu-snu
- munificent 11y ago> I'm inclined to disbelieve any study that claims one gender is better at programming than other The paper makes no such claim. It hypothesizes that women on GitHub may be more competent than men on GitHub. There is a ton of selection pressures involved that determine which set of men and women on Earth end up in the set of people that contribute to open source code on GitHub. So, even if it turns out that one gender is wildly more competent on GitHub than the other, that may or may not say anything about biology or overall gender. Instead, it may simply point to some gender-asymmetry of those selection pressures.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoI am wondering if the data had been the reverse would they have ever made that claim, or would the difference had been explained as the result of some other process?
- anigbrowl 11y agoI love the way that you decided to dismiss the claim on the basis of your personal prior beliefs without bothering to assess the quality of the evidence proffered in support of it. This is not to say the claim is necessarily correct (I see some people critiquing bits of the methodology and of course extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence), but it's unusual to see such a clear statement of cognitive bias as to cause someone to admit up front that they literally chose to ignore the evidence because they were so repelled by the claim of what it demonstrated.
- kstrauser 11y agoMy contentious "personal prior beliefs" are that men and women are equally good at science. My cognitive bias is that I am highly suspect of evidence that purports to show that one is better than the other at thoughtwork. I find that repellant and against everything I've been raised to believe true. So yes, you've got me on this one.
- anigbrowl 11y agoWell I have the same priors but I'm willing to at least consider the possibility that I'm wrong about this. Admittedly I'm married to a lady with EE degree so this wouldn't be the first time I've had to consider that. Inb4 n=1 etc. :-)
- kstrauser 11y agoYeah, my mom was an EE-in-practice and my wife's a surgeon. I'm totally open to being proven wrong. :-) I just don't think this is the study that's going to do it.