4 ms·
PZ Myers had a good take on this a few days ago - http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2016/01/29/how-can-you-protect-a-brain-by-destroying-it/ http://scienceblog
by zimpenfish 11y ago
PZ Myers had a good take on this a few days ago -
http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2016/01/29/how-can-you-protect-a-brain-by-destroying-it/ http://scienceblogs.com/pharyngula/2016/01/29/how-can-you-pr...
> What I didn’t do with my experiments in aldehyde-preserved brains was claim that I was preserving all the information necessary for nervous system function. I was quite aware that I was chemically nuking all the proteins in the tissue; I was washing out most of the chemistry; I was destroying most of the physiological information to preserve a structural skeleton of what was there, so I could see the physical arrangement of the pieces. Nothing more.
- lsparrish 11y agoHis criticism bad (as ever), since he assumes all information needed for nervous system function is the same as all information needed to replicate a given nervous system. Most of the information needed for function in any system is generic across similar systems. We are only interested in the information that is specific to the individual.
- kanzure 11y ago> We are only interested in the information that is specific to the individual. Not necessarily; there's a lot of value to be had in the non-specific information, too.
- lsparrish 11y agoThis technique is useful for general neuroscience purposes, yes. My point was just that it isn't what is critical to preserve for the sake of cryonics.
- cbr 11y agoThe question of whether the physical structure is enough to preserve the information that makes you you is the key thing, and Myers is right to say we should be trying to figure out how to read the information off of very small brains. On the other hand, if you think that the physical structure is sufficient (I don't) then figuring out how to preserve whole human brains is pretty important. There's a long time to figure out how to read the information off the preserved brains, but any unpreserved (or improperly preserved) ones are gone for good. So I see why Hayworth etc are interested in high-quality preservation of larger and larger animals and aren't focusing on the reading portion. "I'm more inclined to believe their goal is to pocket lots of money exploiting people’s fear of death. ... Fruit flies and nematodes won’t pay them a substantial annuity to have their brains vitrified and stored, and their gratitude upon being resurrected wouldn’t be at all remunerative." I've met Hayworth, this really doesn't fit him. He is genuinely interested in better preservation methods as a way to fight death. As a neuroscientist working in connectomics his association with cryonics only hurts him professionally.
- cryonaut 11y agoPZ made the usual error that most biologists make: if it's busted, the information isn't there and can't be recovered. It's dead. The vital spark has departed. It's soul has gone to heaven. Vitalism is alive and well. Ask anyone who owns a computer if you can recover information from the hard drive of a busted computer.