4 ms·
Joel Spolsky gave a great talk a few years ago about the design of StackOverflow. Three groups of people are involved in every question on the site: the asker,
by josephg 11y ago
Joel Spolsky gave a great talk a few years ago about the design of StackOverflow. Three groups of people are involved in every question on the site: the asker, the people who answer and the people who read the answer later. Which group do you think the site is optimised for?
The answer is the third group. The average SO question gets read 30 times per day. Any value captured by either of the other groups is massively dominated by the value captured by people who google the question and land on SO. Complaining about the site being harsh to question askers fundamentally misunderstands the value SO provides to the community.
I'm all for websites which help beginners learn programming, but if you need 1-on-1 help to figure out why your loop is invalid, SO is the wrong site. https://hackhands.com https://hackhands.com might be a better destination.
(I can't find the video on my phone - if somebody could link it below that would be great. )
- cableshaft 11y agoYou're right. SO is optimized for people who read it later. I.e. people who will Google their problem, get directed to the question...and then want to throttle you for answering "Just google it." Because they just did that. And the next eight links on their google search also link to forums with people saying "RTFM", "Quit wasting our time", "This has been answered a bunch of times before.", or even worse, someone who clearly didn't bother to read the question and gives a blatantly wrong answer. And then the answer they have been looking for is now buried in legions of programmers' impulsive expressions of indignation. At the very least link to somewhere where it is properly answered, or don't answer at all.