3 ms·
Yes, because humans are animals. Ignoring humans, while we are different to other animals, we are not really that different, particularly to other social mammal
by contingencies 11y ago
Yes, because humans are animals. Ignoring humans, while we are different to other animals, we are not really that different, particularly to other social mammals. So the answer remains yes.
Note that this answer is self-evident and did not require torturing other beings.
- antientropic 11y agoThis is not at all self-evident, and your logic is flawed: you're saying that X (humans) is a subset of Y (animals), all X have property P (empathy), therefore all Y have property P.
- contingencies 11y agoThe point was that, while you can raise the query from a western scientific reductionist perspective and put ethics completely on hold, we're ridiculously similar genetically and behaviorally, such that the certainty is very high without the need for torture.
- contingencies 11y agoTo put this another way, all science is probability-based. To take your philosophical bent to its logical conclusion, you never know that all animals of a similar species have similar abilities for empathy so you should torture them all!
- Scarblac 11y agoBy this logic, self-evidently other animals also discuss this on their version of Hacker News.