10 ms·
The Brain Is Hardwired to Snap
- cpdean 11y agoR Douglas Fields grossly misinterprets how much people are exposed to influences their behavior. "Something like 90 percent of the people in prison for violent crimes are men." Something about all these people make them terrible humans, but it's not an adrenaline response. He's belittling all the social problems in his book by attributing them to neurological reflexes.
- zzalpha 11y agoNot at all. He's saying that what likely landed many, though probably not all, of them in jail ("snapping") has its basis in neurology, but flat out states that that response is due to numerous outside triggers, including things like stress, and that our responses to those triggers are something we can control once we recognize they're pressing these deeply wired buttons. That said, I do agree, the story as told here is still a bit black and white for my taste. For me it was the heroism angle that threw me... E.g., maybe the majority of decorated vets are men because, until recently, only men were eligible for combat roles.
- colomon 11y agoHe talks about the Carnegie Award for Heroism, which is for civilians: http://www.carnegiehero.org/ http://www.carnegiehero.org/
- metasean 11y agoInteresting that the the "Deed of Trust" starts off, > Gentlemen The first paragraph goes on to talk about supporting widows and children. Thankfully the paragraph does end with, "Grants of sums of money may also be made to heroes or heroines as the Commission thinks advisable-each case to be judged on its merits." But by the third paragraph, it's back to "A medal shall be given to the hero, or widow, or next of kin ..." I'm sure that language doesn't bias anyone on the Commission. [1] http://www.carnegiehero.org/deed-of-trust/ http://www.carnegiehero.org/deed-of-trust/
- zzalpha 11y agoAh, I stand corrected! That's definitely more interesting... begs the question if there's bias in handing out the award, of course, but...
- theworstshill 11y agoAt most its 50% environment, 50% genetic. Its really all about what degree of self control you have. Of course I agree with you in an instant that a poor, less educated society tends to be more violent but environment never paints the whole story.
- astrodust 11y agoI do wonder if incarceration rates are different because women are treated differently at trial for violent offences. It's certainly not the only factor, but it could skew things even further than they would otherwise be. Is it presumed that women are unlikely to reoffend where men are assumed to be likely to? It's like how it's difficult to get female abusers prosecuted for just about anything, including rape or spousal abuse. There's some kind of bias here.
- sjtrny 11y ago> We’ve all been there: Some jerk cuts you off on the highway. You lean on the horn, scream abuse. You want to get out the car and kick the @#$% out of the bozo’s SUV. Nope
- jrcii 11y agoI'm not a psychologist but I believe this qualifies as "projection."
- kjdal2001 11y agoYeah. I know road rage isn't rare, but some people talk about it like its normal behavior. Most people I know, including myself, don't let minor annoyances get to them like that.
- RodericDay 11y agoPeople talk about it like it's normal, which in turn normalizes it. It's a cycle, or a self-fulfilling prophecy.
- jmngomes 11y ago"The AAA Foundation for Traffic Safety found that between 1990 and 1996 road rage contributed to 218 deaths and 12,610 injuries. The study analyzed 10,037 police reports and newspaper stories about traffic accidents that led to violence. What's more, AAA found that road rage incidents increased nearly 7 percent each year within that six-year period." in http://www.apa.org/monitor/jun05/anger.aspx http://www.apa.org/monitor/jun05/anger.aspx
- nothrabannosir 11y agoNot sure what you're trying to say, exactly. "There is proof that road rage exists"? OP didn't say "Road rage doesn't exist", he said "It's not universal". A universal quantifier ("all" or "none") can be disproven with a counter-example (op to article), an existential quantifier ("some" or "not all") can't (you, if I understand it correctly, to op). He's just saying "speak for yourself." Or did you mean something else?
- golemotron 11y ago> When you look at the subject of aggression there is no more important factor than gender. Something like 90 percent of the people in prison for violent crimes are men. Men have different brains than women, which comes from our different roles during evolution, when the brain was formed. Men had a role of being aggressive, which makes no sense for a woman because a woman was not endowed with the physical strength of a man, who probably outweighs her. But although 90 percent of those in jail are men, 90 percent of people who have been awarded medals by the Carnegie Institute for heroism are also men. What is wrong with this guy? Doesn't he know that gender is a social construct?
- vzip 11y agoIt's kind of frightening that people are leaving university with a developed hostility toward the notion of sexual dimorphism in humans.
- sarciszewski 11y agoTo split hairs a bit: Gender identity is a social construct while biological sex is not. I think the author meant sex, not gender, and GP meant gender, not sex. It's easy to conflate the two in conversation, but keeping a semantic barrier between them will help maintain civil discourse without the risk of devolving the discussion into a flame war.
- goda90 11y agoThe thing is, gender identity is very much affected by sex too. Many outward behaviors that are often classified as masculine or feminine have roots in different hormone levels in the sexes. That's why I dislike that many attack gender roles and other social gender norms indiscriminately. Some of them have a basis in nature and it's healthy for the vast majority of people to embrace them. At the same time there shouldn't be any room for attacking those who don't follow the norms either. And of course some norms are just harmful. It's not so easy to just throw them all out.
- 11y ago
- norea-armozel 11y agoI remember when I was younger I would snap at the silliest moments, mostly when I wasn't getting my way. This went on for about 16 years, so there was a point I was very dangerous to be around if I lost it. What I find interesting looking back is how now I don't really get all that mad and at worse I'll just snarky or rude. I don't know what's changed over time (hormones maybe?) but I do know that unless someone really pushed me I probably wouldn't go into a ragefit.
- jschwartzi 11y agoPart of the function of your frontal lobes is to moderate impulses, and they actually continue growing and maturing for several years past age 18. It sounds like you just had a little more growing up to do.
- norea-armozel 11y agoThis is somewhat true, but I actually use to be very verbally abusive until three years ago. Then again I was dealing with not even having a therapist to talk about my gender dysphoria (not being out sucks for me). So who knows wth is going on with me.
- astazangasta 11y agoI'd just like to take this to task for how much supposition is floating around. Early on we are introduced to the idea of snapping via an anecdote. We are given a neuronal hook via something called a 'hypothalamic attack region', which produces rage in rats. Is this region responsible for the opening episode of rage? We have no idea; it is pure speculation to assume it is. All of the subsequent examples (crime, heroism) are imputed to this circuit similarly without evidence. Then we are given a model (LIFEMORTS), which is extended to cover race relations and much else. We are told our thinking is 'tribal'; we are expected to believe this is science, because recall the existence of the hypothalamus attack region! But there is no evidence chaining these three together (neurons, the model, the behavior) - we have zero reason to accept the model view of what happened in Baltimore. It is pure speculation.
- mystic001 11y ago"We’re constantly dividing people into “us” vs. “them.” And once we put someone in the “them” category, it can open up the floodgates for violence and is the root of a lot of human misery and wars." Some may call this naive, but this is the reason we need more unity in the world. Less division. More us...less us and them. The media seems to do a great job of pitting one side against the other. I think many of our attitudes and perspectives are learned and perpetuated by the media.
- ooo000ooo 11y ago> Some may call this naive, but this is the reason we need more unity in the world. Less division. More us...less us and them. Then you have learned nothing. The tribalism in humans is hardwired. It's not going away, whatever we may wish or do. The media doesn't create the divisions, they just profit from them. The key to peaceful coexistence is properly delineated regions and nations, so that each thede can have their land without being afraid of being invaded and replaced.
- bonoboTP 11y agoBut divison is not just about nations. 1) It's also political differences in the same nation. Tribes fragment to smaller tribes, small tribes merge to large tribes etc. 2) There are divisions based on topics of interest, subcultures, etc. that aren't location-based, but thanks to telecommunications, global.
- ooo000ooo 11y ago> Tribes fragment to smaller tribes, small tribes merge to large tribes etc. When boundaries can change slowly enough we don't even notice. That's organic growth, that's ok. > that aren't location-based, but thanks to telecommunications, global. Thankfully I only have to close the browser tab to forget about someone Who is Wrong On The Internet. But I can't do that in meatspace.
- mystic001 11y agoHasn't history shown us that this doesn't work?
- fiatmoney 11y ago"Violence: A Micro-Sociological Theory" is an excellent book on related subjects.