4 ms·
> As the Earth's distance from a star increases, it subtends a decreasing angle in that star's "sky." But the number of stars at a given distance increases as
by pdonis 11y ago
> As the Earth's distance from a star increases, it subtends a decreasing angle in that star's "sky."
But the number of stars at a given distance increases as the distance increases, and this increase exactly cancels out the decrease in the amount of light from a given star that reaches the Earth. So your argument does not explain why the night sky is dark.
> Now divide the surface area of the dot, by the surface area of the sphere (4)(pi)(r^2). That's how much of that star's energy our planet catches.
Now do it the other way: draw a sphere around the Earth with some radius r. Calculate how many stars are on that sphere. The number increases as r^2; and, as you have shown, the amount of light reaching Earth from a given star decreases as r^2. So, as I said above, the increase in the number of stars exactly cancels out the decrease in the amount of light from each star that reaches the Earth; thus, the total starlight reaching Earth from a given radius r is a constant, independent of r.
- rdiddly 11y agoThere's no reason to believe the universe is infinite nor that stars are evenly distributed throughout its volume. So "the number of stars increases as r^2" is the part that doesn't hold and is causing the paradox.
- mannykannot 11y agoThis is Kepler's theory, and it gets into philosophical trouble, as cosmologists generally take it as axiomatic that the laws of physics are the same everywhere, and so don't have much time for theories that depend on us being in a special place in the universe. A universe having a lower density of stars everywhere above some radius from Earth does put us in a special place, is hard to reconcile with universal laws, and there is no empirical evidence for it. An explanation that derives from the universe evolving over time, however, has none of the philosophical problems and does have supporting empirical evidence.
- pdonis 11y ago> There's no reason to believe the universe is infinite nor that stars are evenly distributed throughout its volume. There is if you believe General Relativity is correct as applied to the universe as a whole. And if you don't, you have no model at all with which to make any predictions about what we should observe, so there's no reason to believe anything.