3 ms·
At the risk of going more-pedantic-than-thou, this entire thread of nitpicks (and indeed, most of the posts I see right now to this story in general) is(/are) m
by jerf 11y ago
At the risk of going more-pedantic-than-thou, this entire thread of nitpicks (and indeed, most of the posts I see right now to this story in general) is(/are) mostly irrelevant. The argument is not particularly sensitive to the exact way in which the universe is not steady state, including redshifting all the light until we're not staring at the sun in every direction. Olber's Paradox disproves the Steady State hypothesis, it doesn't positively prove anything in particular. Popular treatments of Olber's Paradox are not obligated to come attached to a complete course in cosmology. I'm sure at least one of "Steven Soter and Neil deGrasse Tyson" are fully aware of all the issues raised in this entire HN page.
- goodside 11y agoThere are plenty of ways the Universe could be steady-state and still not have a white-hot sky. Suppose you have metric expansion as you do now, but new matter magically appears as a sparse, uniform cloud of particles throughout space to feed the creation of new stars and maintain the energy density we see today. Metric expansion guarantees that light is redshifted in proportion to distance, so the sky remains dark, even though the Universe is infinitely old and stable. This model is wrong, obviously, but the reason has nothing to do with Olber's paradox.
- jerf 11y agoThe Steady State hypothesis isn't really a class of hypotheses, it was a specific one. The Steady State hypothesis predates the entire concept of metric expansion, after all. History, everyone. Olber's paradox is important because of the history, not its relevance to 21st century physics.
- goodside 11y agoThe model I described is the historical model, as developed (and later repudiated) by Einstein. It does not "predate the entire concept of metric expansion". The whole point was to reconcile expansion, which was both predicted by GR and confirmed by Hubble's observation of recessional redshift, with the belief that the Universe was infinitely old and unchanging. And there were many variants of Steady State, as the model was discovered independently after Einstein, and refined throughout the 1950s as its adherents struggled to explain new observations that distant quasars are far more common than near ones. There was even a brief (and apparently failed) attempt by Hoyle to revive a Steady State as late as 1993, involving widely varying rates of expansion in different regions of the Universe. What ultimately disproved Steady State was seeing the CMBR. None of this has anything to do with Olber's paradox, which is not an issue in a Steady State model for exactly the same reasons it's not an issue in modern cosmology.