6 ms·
>In the “friends of the court” brief, it says the law was never intended to “permit a wealthy for-profit entity to digitize millions of works and to cut off aut
by epistasis 11y ago
>In the “friends of the court” brief, it says the law was never intended to “permit a wealthy for-profit entity to digitize millions of works and to cut off authors’ licensing of their reproduction, distribution, and public display rights.”
This "cutoff" language is part of what makes the Author's Guild argument fall down. The authors still get all the normal licensing rights as before, so the argument appears wrong on its very face.
What the guild is actually trying to say, I think, is that this new use is something Google should have to pay for. Which is a stronger argument, because it's not trivially refuted by the current status. By overstating their case I think that their point is lost.
- criddell 11y ago> What the guild is actually trying to say, I think, is that this new use is something Google should have to pay for. That doesn't make sense to me. Books are no different than any other material, are they? If Google indexes this page, should they have to first get permission and pay somebody (us or maybe HN).
- jim-greer 11y agoFair use allows for this kind of thing, but is fuzzy: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use The web is a little different. One factor is that robots.txt is effectively an opt-out. But no, in general indexing a site doesn't require permission.
- criddell 11y agoRight, and I'm saying that indexing a book shouldn't require permission either. Just as you can use robots.txt to opt out of indexing, so can you contact Google and tell them to remove your work from their index.
- jim-greer 11y agoWhoops, misread your comment. Agreed.
- thedanfilter 11y agoBut they aren't just indexing the book. They are copying it completely. Then using that copy to provide a commercial service to people that reinforces the Google brand. In a similar way, I could _borrow_ books from the library, take them home and digitise them, then return the library book while retaining the digital _copy_. I'm pretty sure this is not allowed under copyright law. However, if I go one step further, commercialising my collection of digitised books by providing them online to everyone in the world in a searchable format - but removing every few pages - that somehow makes the original copyright infringement legal?... Does Google Books provide a useful service? I think Yes. Do they infringe copyright to do it? I think Yes. How could they not infringe copyright? I suggest if they bought every book that they digitise, they would then have the right to index those books so that they could offer their fair use service to people. Optionally, publishing houses and authors could opt-in to the system by providing them with a free book or a waiver.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> In a similar way, I could _borrow_ books from the library, take them home and digitise them, then return the library book while retaining the digital _copy_. I'm pretty sure this is not allowed under copyright law. Its, on first glance, a violation of the copyright owner's exclusive rights to create copies, sure. Whether its actually infringement or not depends on whether it falls in one of the exceptions to the exclusive rights, such as fair use. Copying a library book and just to keep it for yourself does not seem likely to do that. > However, if I go one step further, commercialising my collection of digitised books by providing them online to everyone in the world in a searchable format - but removing every few pages - that somehow makes the original copyright infringement legal?... Quite possibly. Fair use is funny that way, because the boundaries are not crisply defined but anything that falls within it is an exception to the exclusive rights of copyright, transforming what would otherwise be infringement into non-infringement. > I suggest if they bought every book that they digitise, they would then have the right to index those books so that they could offer their fair use service to people. If the service is fair use, then whether they own physical copies or not is immaterial, since the users ownership of physical copies of the work is not one of the factors called to be considered in fair use analysis. You don't acquire a right to fair use of a copyrighted work by purchasing a copy of the work, everyone has an inherent right to fair use (which was a judicially identified limitation of Constitutional character before being enshrined in statute) inherently.
- apress 11y agoPublishers can opt out of the book indexing, too (kind of like robots.txt) https://www.google.com/googlebooks/publisher_library.html https://www.google.com/googlebooks/publisher_library.html
- derekp7 11y agoBasically, they are saying that if anyone makes a profit off their work, they deserve a cut of it. Makes sense on the surface of it, but let's try applying this to other categories. Take for example a food critic. He makes his living from reviewing the creative output of various chefs. Without the chefs doing what they do, the critic wouldn't have an audience and therefore no newspaper column. So do the chefs deserve a cut of the critic's revenue? Of course a favorable review does tend to drive extra traffic to the restaurant, just as a positive match in Google Books can drive a sale to a given book.
- lelandbatey 11y agoI like your example quite a lot. I feel like if Google where providing a service that only indexed books, but did not provide any content, the authors guild would not have a leg to stand on. In this altered Google Books service, let's say I search for the following phrase: Then they were looking at the familiar environs of the ISS Flight Control Room, which was at Johnson Space Center in Houston. The director of mission operations was sitting in front of the camera stroking his iPad. He didn't seem to be aware that the camera was on. This "alternate universe Google Books" would present you with only the following information: Book: Seveneves Author: Neil Stephenson Quote is found on page: XXXX [ CLICK HERE TO BUY THIS BOOK! ] The functionality of being a "Book search engine" would remain, without reproducing any copyrighted material. I imagine that this alternate version of Google Books would not incur any ire from the Authors Guild, or if they did take issue, Google's use of their books would be firmly upheld as fair use. As it stands now, Google Books shows you some of each book you search for, and I suspect that's what the Authors Guild cares about.
- derekp7 11y agoThe thing is, often times (and I'm assuming it is based on concessions with book publishers) they only show a very small amount of context for the quote -- just enough so you can make a decision if that was really what you were looking for (essentially what falls under common fair use guidelines). And they do have links to purchase the book.