4 ms·
I tried to sign up to check it out and got some bullshit about... "Your request to join Woo's closed beta has been sent." I'd want to use this site as a hiring
by latchkey 11y ago
I tried to sign up to check it out and got some bullshit about... "Your request to join Woo's closed beta has been sent."
I'd want to use this site as a hiring tool (and wanted to see what the experience is like from the person signing up), but if they aren't even allowing people to sign up without going through some 'beta' process, I can't see how they would have anyone using their site.
Why is this at the top of hackernews?
- sbierwagen 11y agoAstroturfing.
- bduerst 11y agoSomething fishy is going on with new HN accounts created right after this was posted: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=ajax_freak https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=ajax_freak https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=hws100 https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=hws100 https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=rivalz https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=rivalz
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dang 11y agoActually, this is an interesting case. It looks to me like the early votes were real, but then a bunch of later voters showed up to promote the story. Perhaps teammates got wind of their startup being on HN. All: promotional voting is bad on HN. It's against the rules, users hate it and are good at detecting it, and we penalize accounts and sites that do it. In this case, though, there clearly was some real community interest, so we've reduced the penalty on the story. Hopefully the thread can focus on the actual startup now.
- sanderjd 11y agoHonest question: if in the future a company I work for is submitted to HN and I notice, should I really not upvote it? That seems like it would be a really unnatural reaction.
- dang 11y agoAn isolated vote won't make a difference. If a bunch of people have the same reaction, that might be indistinguishable from a voting ring.
- BorisMelnik 11y agothats the risk with these type of launches. I'm sure the founders were aware of this type of reaction. Its just a gamble.
- Nimitzzz 11y agoHi I'm from the WOO team, the reason for a closed beta is because we want to control the quality of candidates however you are a HN user which is why we created a link to HN users to bypass the invite - here it is: https://woo.io/eng/useinvite?token=1085A2AA0E9B89D90AF94BCD0596458E https://woo.io/eng/useinvite?token=1085A2AA0E9B89D90AF94BCD0...
- latchkey 11y agoTwo day old HN account? No, I won't be using your 'service' or clicking on your special link. If the only way to control the quality of people using your site is through special links, then your business won't be very successful.
- sanderjd 11y agoWhy is your comment so harsh? Why did you put scare quotes around "service"? What's wrong with them providing a special invite link when people here were complaining about their closed beta? For that matter, why are people complaining about a closed beta? Seriously folks, what in the world is with the insanely uncharitable reaction here to someone launching a service targeted at developers and their employers and it being linked on HN? This is completely relevant content!
- latchkey 11y agoI'm a founder and I'm a developer. I'm not only hiring people aggressively (thanks to a successful startup) but I'm also spending a lot of time coding. I spent my arguably valuable time to try out their service from both roles and my time was wasted because their service isn't usable and / or ready to be on the front page of HN. I call bullshit on the beta and the response. Nowhere in the signup process was there any sort of notification that I would have to wait to get access. Nowhere on the site does it say 'beta'. I shouldn't have to enter my information in order to find this out. If they wanted to make something special for HN readers, then look at the referrer. No need for special links.
- 11y ago
- hsod 11y agoWhy is a closed beta such a "bullshit" concept? I see start-ups do this all the time, it makes sense to me. Either to manage scaling (Gmail) or to control the quality of the users on the site.